Commentary Magazine


Contentions

Commentary of the Day

Alenda Lux, on Abe Greenwald:

If we’re going to rebuild the Reagan Majority, various types of conservatives are going to have to accept aspects of the other types of conservatives. With the exception of some (like the Huckabee types), social conservatives are willing to accept fiscal conservatism, and often are fiscal conservatives themselves. The top ranked Senators and Congressmen on the Club for Growth’s rating charts all got 100% from Right to Life. Those social cons who don’t practice fiscal conservatism generally do so not because of a principled objection to it (Huckabee) but because they’re power hungry. That hardly can be blamed on social conservatism.

Are fiscal conservatives/social liberals really that opposed to social conservatives? Roberts, Alito, partial birth abortion ban, Born Alive, etc. Are those really that objectionable? Is it really so bad to have a referendum on redefining the institution of marriage? Isn’t that, um, democracy? If we’re going to be a majority again, fiscal conservatives have to be willing to meet social conservatives half way too.