Commentary Magazine


Posts For: October 3, 2011

Power Has its Duties as Well as its Rights

What makes this particular moment in politics particularly interesting and important is that we’re engaged in a fundamental debate about the role of state in our lives. The Obama presidency has created something of an inflection point. We have to choose which path we want America to travel down — one that resembles the European welfare state or a return to constitutionalism and a federal government of limited and enumerated powers.

But during the weekend I was reminded about the danger of framing this debate in too binary a fashion. The reminder came in the form of an impromptu speech made by John Fletcher Moulton, a noted English judge, parliamentarian and administrator, which was reprinted in the July 1924 issue of The Atlantic Monthly.

Read More

Obama Shared Podium With Virulent Anti-Semite in ‘07

Andrew Breitbart may have scooped the mainstream media once again, publishing photos of then-Senator Obama appearing to share a stage with members of the New Black Panther Party and leader Malik Shabazz, during his presidential campaign in 2007:

Among those appearing with Obama was Shabazz, the Panther leader who was one of the defendants in the voter intimidation case that Attorney General Eric Holder dismissed. Also present was the Panthers’ “Minister of War,” Najee Muhammed, who had called for murdering Dekalb County, Georgia, police officers with AK-47s and then mocking their widows in this video (7:20 – 8:29).

Injustice includes a disturbing photo of Shabazz and the Panthers marching behind Obama with raised fists in the “Black Power” salute.

Read More

Cain Declares Open Season on Perry

The Rick Perry campaign is dealing with the fallout from the Washington Post story about the racist name of the hunting camp the candidate’s family leased for more than 20 years. But though some conservatives were ready to defend Perry from what they believed was a slanted and poorly documented attack from the mainstream media, the decision of rival Republican presidential candidate Herman Cain to jump on Perry over his association with the “Niggerhead” camp compounds the Texas governor’s problems.

Cain told Fox News Sunday, “There isn’t a more vile, negative word than the N-word and for him to leave it there as long as he did before, I hear, that they finally painted over it, is just plain insensitive to a lot of black people in this country.”

Read More

Is Christie the High-Risk, High-Reward Candidate?

In his column comparing Chris Christie to Hillary Clinton as she agonized over whether to run for president in 2004, John Heilemann makes a strong point about a politician’s “moment,” but loses control of his analogy as he attempts to render a final judgment on Clinton’s ultimate decision. I think many are making a similar mistake with Christie. Heilemann writes:

Clinton weighed the possibility all the way into November. In the end, however, Hillary concluded it was just too soon for her to make a presidential run. That voters would punish her for breaking a campaign vow to serve her first Senate term in full. That 2004 was not, in fact, her time—2008 or 2012 would be. Clinton’s assessment was rational, conventional, and highly prudent. But then the big wheel of history turned and rendered it mistaken.

Read More

Study: Voter ID Laws Could Impact Millions

This report by the Brennan Center is making the rounds on liberal blogs today, with its sensational finding that new voting laws could disenfranchise five million eligible voters. According to the study:

•   These new laws could make it significantly harder for more than five million eligible voters to cast ballots in 2012.

•   The states that have already cut back on voting rights will provide 171 electoral votes in 2012– 63 percent of the 270 needed to win the presidency.

•   Of the 12 likely battleground states, as assessed by an August Los Angeles Times analysis of Gallup polling, five have already cut back on voting rights (and may pass additional restrictive legislation), and two more are currently considering new restrictions.

Read More

The Psychodrama of the Obama Presidency

According to President Obama, America has “gotten a little soft” during the last few decades. That revelation is a relatively new one for Obama, who during the campaign assured us that “We are the ones we’ve been waiting for.” As Obama hop-scotched around the country, he informed us that “We are the hope of the future – the answer to the cynics who tell us … we cannot remake this world as it should be.” Back then, “what began as a whisper has now swelled to a chorus that cannot be ignored, that will not be deterred, that will ring out across this land as a hymn that will heal this nation, repair this world, make this time different than all the rest.” (I’d urge you to take a look at this campaign video and see if you miss the reference to America having gone a “little soft.”)

Let’s see if we can make sense of this, shall we?

Read More

Obama’s Polling Compared to Predecessors

It’s a bad sign when Jimmy Carter’s poll numbers actually start to look respectable. From AEI’s public opinion expert Karlyn Browman and researcher Andrew Rugg:

President Obama looks worse than any recent incumbent president when the public assesses the country’s direction, consumer confidence, personal financial appraisals, and job approval at this point in time.

Read More

Panetta’s Pointless Warning to Israel

Defense Secretary Leon Panetta warned Israel yesterday that its increasing isolation in the region means it must take “risks for peace.” This shot fired over the bow of Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu was made in comments to reporters traveling with Panetta, who is on his first trip to the Jewish state since assuming the leadership of the Pentagon.

But it is not likely to make much of an impression with the Israeli people for the simple reason that, unlike either the Obama administration and the international press corps, they understand Israel has been taking risks for peace for 18 years. Panetta’s statement, like so much of the rhetoric that has come out of the administration, seems to reflect a mindset that treats the events of the last 18 years as meaningless. After the Oslo Accords, the peace offers that both Yasir Arafat and Mahmoud Abbas rejected and the withdrawal from Gaza that turned that area into a terrorist state, how can any American speak as if Israel has stood pat all this time rather than, as the historical record proves, taken terrible risks for which it has gotten little reward?

Read More

Obama Campaign: Christie Lacks Experience

The fact that the “inexperience” argument is being made by Obama campaign surrogate Gov. Deval Patrick, who was pilloried for his own thin resume when he ran for governor, makes it all the more interesting. It’s hard to imagine this attack line working for the Obama campaign, especially after it spent most of the 2008 election touting his “outsider” status and downplaying the importance of political experience.

From Meet the Press yesterday:

GOV. PATRICK: Sure. I like Chris [Christie]. He’s, he’s, he’s one of my favorites. I’m not going to–I don’t, you know, I wish him well. Not that well.

GOV. McDONNELL: You hear that endorsement?

GOV. PATRICK: No, that’s not what that was. But I–look, you know, he’s been governor for, what is it, a year and a half, two years?

GOV. McDONNELL: Yeah.

GOV. PATRICK: I think unemployment in New Jersey is higher even than, than the national average. It’s some unfinished work in New Jersey in order to have proof points for the case he wants to make.

Read More

Survey Says: Advantage GOP

According to a new Gallup survey, Americans see the Republican Party as better able than the Democratic Party to protect the country from terrorism and military threats, which is not all that unusual (the margin is 49 percent v. 38 percent). But they also see the GOP as better able than the Democratic Party to keep the country prosperous during the next few years, and that is unusual.

Democrats held the advantage over the Republican Party on the “prosperous” dimension from 2003 through 2009 – including by 20 points as recently as three years ago. But the advantage switched to the GOP last year and remains so this year, by 48 percent to 39 percent.

Read More

Time to Get Tough With Pakistan

In an editorial in the new Weekly Standard, I argue that, following Admiral Mike Mullen’s revelations about Pakistani involvement in the Haqqani network’s attacks on the U.S. embassy in Kabul and other American targets, it is time to get tough with Pakistan. I suggest we start treating Pakistan’s Inter-Services Intelligence Agency the way we treated Iran’s Quds Force in Iraq. That is to say, apply the full range of our power–everything from diplomatic pressure, economic sanctions, to kinetic military action–to curb the menace posed by this group. The case for such action is made stronger by this report in USA Today:

Pakistan is the source of explosives in the vast majority of makeshift bombs insurgents in Afghanistan planted this summer to attack U.S. troops, according to U.S. military commanders.

Read More

Why did the State Department Give Ahmadinejad’s Son a Visa?

It has become common for foreign leaders to invite large delegations to New York for the United Nations General Assembly. Most delegation members are not diplomats, have no business at the UN, and are in New York only for the shopping and partying. For friendly countries, providing these add-on delegates visas is both a courtesy and good for business. Adversaries, however, should receive no such courtesy. While the United States must as host provide enemy leaders and aides with visas, there is no reason why the State Department should allow the abuse of this privilege.

Alas, no one told the good folks at Foggy Bottom. The State Department evidently granted not only Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad’s son but also his daughter-in-law a visa. Here are pictures of them in New York courtesy of the Iranian website Asr-e Iran. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton owes the American people an explanation.

Axelrod: Voter Apathy Led Us Into Iraq

So if the war in Iraq was simply a matter of voter apathy, what does that say about voter “enthusiasm” in 2008? We’re still in Iraq, and likely to remain there past the January 2012 deadline President Obama set during his campaign. And yet Americans aren’t concerned about that – they’re far more worried about the economy.

David Axelrod’s outreach to the anti-war movement during an interview with the Harvard Crimson might also be slightly less ridiculous if movement leaders weren’t calling for Obama’s arrest for “war crimes”:

Read More

Peter Gent, 1942–2011

Peter Gent, a backup wide receiver for the Dallas Cowboys who went on to write novels about professional football, has died in Bangor, Michigan, of pulmonary disease. He was 69.

After a five-year career in Dallas, during which he caught 68 passes for 989 yards and four touchdowns, Gent retired to write North Dallas Forty, a 1973 exposé in fiction. Life in the NFL had left Gent deeply divided. “In one sense, you’re a folk hero,” he said. “But you’re really someone else’s property: your life subject to change by a single phone call.”

North Dallas Forty was about eight days in the declining football career of Phil Elliott, a receiver for the North Dallas Bulls. Before he is suspended by the NFL commissioner for drug use, Elliott is benched in favor of a young hotshot, although he knows he is the better pass-catcher. From that vantage point, Elliott serves up reflections about his teammates and their fans:

Looking up into the stands at the mass of gray dots that were faces, perched atop flashes of colors that expressed their egos, I suddenly realized how peculiar we [players] must look. I thought of Al Capp paying six dollars a head to watch and scream while trained mice scurried around in panic.

The novel was widely read as a roman à clef rather than an exposé — the fast-living quarterback was obviously modeled on the Cowboys’ Don Meredith, the robotic coach on Tom Landry — and though it was later filmed with Nick Nolte playing Gent’s role, North Dallas Forty was a victim of its own timeliness. It ceased being a scandal when Meredith and Landry ceased being gossiped about. Its social commentary wasn’t original or particularly sharp even when its football was still news.

In 1984, in one of my first published reviews, I briefly summarized Gent’s third novel The Franchise in the New York Times Book Review:

Peter Gent, who used to catch passes for the Dallas Cowboys, now writes novels full of rage and bitterness at pro football. “I don’t want revenge, I want the truth known,” one of his characters says. That could serve as Mr. Gent’s motto. The Franchise, his third novel, is a long and thickly woven work — his most ambitious to date. Its title refers to both an expansion football team named the Texas Pistols and to Taylor Rusk, the quarterback who within three seasons turns his team into a Super Bowl contender. The story is focused primarily on the behind-the-scenes struggle to control the new Texas franchise and the league. Characters barter and cheat and sell each other out, engage in “creative financing” and obtain stolen game plans, but there is remarkably little depiction of action on the field. In fact, the central puzzle about The Franchise is the question, for whom is it intended? Football fans will be disappointed by the lack of football and dismayed by Mr. Gent’s relentlessness in tracing the corruption of a sport that finances itself upon “the working stiffs,” that is, the players and fans. Those who love literature will wince as the book alternately reads like a screed, then like an attempt to resurrect the proletarian novel. But the authority and command with which Mr. Gent writes are nonetheless impressive. Unfortunately, in The Franchise he has not submitted that talent to the strictures of plot and selectivity that might have made this a more satisfying novel.

Gent’s best book is probably his touching memoir The Last Magic Summer: A Season with My Son (1996). Although he was in position to do so, he never wrote the definitive football novel, which, indeed, remains to be written. Rest in peace.