On October 12, I wrote in Contentions to take issue with an article published in the Forward by former New York District Attorney Robert M. Morgenthau and New York University Law Professor Frank Tuerkheimer in which the two attempted to cite the American involvement in the North African campaign during World War II as proof that Franklin Roosevelt had successfully saved the Jews of North Africa and British Mandate Palestine. They have replied to that post with the following letter. My response to their letter follows.
Jonathan Tobin’s response to our article addresses both an issue we did not raise and ignores the geography and realities of the North Africa campaign. We wrote that after the Pearl Harbor attack by Japan that Roosevelt adopted a “Germany first” policy, a politically unattractive plan to defeat Germany, the enemy that had not actually attacked us. Roosevelt sensed that “German control over an industrial Europe would pose far greater danger to the United States in the long run.”




