Commentary Magazine


Contentions

The Chilling Candor of Mahmoud Abbas

Thanks to the invaluable work of MEMRI, we can watch Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas declare, in an October 23 interview with Egyptian television, a clarifying statement: “I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again,” Abbas said. “I will never recognize the Jewishness of the state, or a ‘Jewish state.’”

We’re repeatedly told that the issues surrounding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict are enormously complicated, solvable only by diplomats of unusual skill and ability, and that Israel, always Israel, must take a “chance for peace.” But in its most important respects this conflict, at its core,  is quite simple: the Palestinians have yet to make their own inner peace with the existence of a Jewish state. Every failed effort at peace, beginning before Oslo and to this very day, can be traced back to this fundamental truth. Because it is an unpleasant one, many people in the West have simply refused to accept it. It is too unsettling to their premises and presuppositions. And so they proceed in self-deception, demanding that Israel make concessions with a “peace partner” that is, in fact, an implacable and lethal enemy.

Tactically “we may win or lose,” Faisal Husseini, a supposedly moderate figure in Yasir Arafat’s Palestinian Authority, said a decade ago. “But our yes will continue to aspire to the strategic goal, namely, to Palestine from the [Jordan] rive to the [Mediterranean] sea.”

“Whatever we get now,” he added, “cannot make us forget this supreme truth.”

That remains, now as ever, the “supreme truth” guiding the Palestinian leadership. As long as it does–as long as the malignant and murderous pathologies that afflict the Palestinian and Arab world remain–it is folly to pretend real peace is possible. Illusions, even soothing illusions, are never a substitute for reality. We have seen time and time again that basing diplomatic hopes on false assumptions is not a road to peace; it is, rather, the surest road to failure, to tragedy, and to war. I understand that this is an unpopular thing to say; but that doesn’t make it any less true or any less obvious.


Introducing Commentary Complete

2 Responses to “The Chilling Candor of Mahmoud Abbas”

  1. No suprises there. The Palestinians entire identity is the negation of Israel – that is why they were created as a 'people' in the first place. n nRecognizing Israel as Jewish means going against their very nature/mission. n nStill, it is surprising that Abbas, with the world's wind at his back, isn;t even prepared to lie, temporarily, about accepting Israel as a Jewish state to get more concessions, and then renege. Its not like the 'world' would force him to give up the pocketed concessions. Quite the contrary. n nThis shows up Abbas as uniquely cowardly, as far as Palestinian leaders go. n nAs for he 'illusions', I don't think people have any illusions. They whole game is meant to force Israel into a death spiral.

  2. ezra says:

    It should be noted that this interview directly contradicts Abbas' assertion (on Israeli TV) that the Arabs "made a mistake" by rejecting the 1947 partition resolution — inasmuch as that document specifically split Palestine into an Arab state and a Jewish state

Leave a Reply