Commentary Magazine


Contentions

Hersh: U.S. Trained M.E.K. in Nevada

No, not at Area 51, but speaking of conspiracy theories, here’s Seymour Hersh in The New Yorker:

Despite the growing ties, and a much-intensified lobbying effort organized by its advocates, M.E.K. [Mujahideen-e-Khalq] has remained on the State Department’s list of foreign terrorist organizations—which meant that secrecy was essential in the Nevada training. “We did train them here, and washed them through the Energy Department because the D.O.E. owns all this land in southern Nevada,” a former senior American intelligence official told me. “We were deploying them over long distances in the desert and mountains, and building their capacity in communications—coördinating commo is a big deal.” (A spokesman for J.S.O.C. said that “U.S. Special Operations Forces were neither aware of nor involved in the training of M.E.K. members.”) …

It was the ad-hoc training that provoked the worried telephone calls to him, the former general said. “I told one of the guys who called me that they were all in over their heads, and all of them could end up trouble unless they got something in writing. The Iranians are very, very good at counterintelligence, and stuff like this is just too hard to contain.” The site in Nevada was being utilized at the same time, he said, for advanced training of élite Iraqi combat units. (The retired general said he only knew of the one M.E.K.-affiliated group that went though the training course; the former senior intelligence official said that he was aware of training that went on through 2007.)

It’s even more difficult to take Hersh seriously after reading Jamie Kirchick’s persuasive takedown of his work in last month’s COMMENTARY, and this Nevada training scenario seems particularly unrealistic. If true, it would be an enormous scandal. But why would Joint Special Operations Command go through the trouble and risk of bringing members of a terrorist group back to the U.S. for training, when the U.S. controlled an entire military base full of M.E.K. members, Camp Ashraf, in Iraq? And there has been no indication that any training was going on there, so why would it take place at a Department of Energy facility in Nevada?

There’s reason to believe that Israel may have provided the M.E.K. with training and worked with the group on assassinations in Iran. Which seems to make it even less likely that the U.S. would do the same thing, particularly inside the country, with all the security and legal hazards that would carry.

Unfortunately, Hersh provides the sort of storyline that benefits both the M.E.K. and its enemies. A Washington attorney for the M.E.K., and a British defector who now works against the group, were two of the only people quoted who didn’t remain anonymous in Hersh’s story (though neither actually confirmed that the Nevada training took place). Why is that? Because it helps the M.E.K.’s lobbying efforts to get removed from the U.S. list of designated terrorist groups if it gives the impression that members went through training on U.S. soil. And proponents of the Iranian regimes love to find ways to try to tie the U.S. to the M.E.K., a theory that fits flawlessly into their anti-American worldview.

Introducing Commentary Complete

6 Responses to “Hersh: U.S. Trained M.E.K. in Nevada”

  1. Empress_Trudy says:

    To me at least it only serves to point out the silliness of the far left who already openly embrace Hamas and others on this terrorist list. They do seem awfully selective in their outrage. Greenwald covers this in his column at Salon today and his entire argument is that they're TERRORISTS!!!!! ZOMG! Coming from a guy who wants literally every person in Gitmo released, compensated and given a pony and a pat on the head, this is terribly arch. I never hear Greenwald and his ilk complaining about neonazi militias training in the US. Odd, no?

  2. besht2003 says:

    Those MEK guys have suffered some terrible abuse at Ashraf. Hersh is just another moronic crackpot anti-Semite for the rev and chablis set. But I repeat myself.

  3. pooya2011 says:

    Yet another fabricated story by Hersch about Iran and MEK. This story, similar to other ones before it, relies on "anonymous" sources and Iranian intelligence agents and is designed to divert attention from the plight of 3400 MEK members in Camp Ashraf/Liberty, Iraq.

  4. Ali says:

    Hersh you can go to hell. how much have you being payed by the Iranian regime to come up with these thoughts. n

  5. Ed Alberts says:

    Remember that the reason why the Department of Energy owns all that land (and why they aren't so amicable to random folks wandering all over it) is that it was used to test nukes back before anyone really understood them. It isn't that people didn't care about the environment back then or that folks particularly didn't consider that particular "wasteland" worth caring about as much as that they neither really had any idea of what they were doing nor how much of a mess they would be making in the process of doing it. n nForget little green men, there likely are some spots out there so radioactive that they well may glow in the dark — real radiation that any kind of instrumentation will pick up. n nAnyone care to speculate as to what our government might actually be doing out there — assuming for the sake of argument that our government is actually (a) competent and (b) acting in our best interests — what it might really be doing out there?

  6. Raoul Duke says:

    Seymour Hersch is an unabashed purveyor of half baked liberal conspiracy theories. Vanity Fair and the New Yorker eat this stuff up like dog food. I'm waiting for his Roswell expose….I can see it now….aliens landed in New Mexico by accident, they were actually aiming for Texas and the Bush family….according to close sources who cannot be named.

Leave a Reply