Commentary Magazine


Contentions

Killing is Grim Reminder of Stymied Progress in Talks with Taliban

So another member of the Afghan High Peace Council, charged with striking a deal with the Taliban, has been assassinated. Mullah Arsala Rahmani’s demise, at the hands of an unknown gunman, comes less than a year after the assassination, by a suicide bomber, of the head of the peace council, former president Burhanuddin Rabbani.

You would think this would signal, as clearly as anything could, the contempt in which the Taliban hold peace talks. Yet, rest assured, this will not deter policymakers in Washington from making peace talks a central pillar of their Afghanistan policy. This relentless commitment to something so impractical is only the latest manifestation of that all too common Washington phenomenon: making policy based on hope, not reality, and substituting wishful thinking for actual evidence.

Perhaps, before we pour any more energy into the “peace talks” boondoggle, someone could actually point to some concrete evidence that the Taliban leaders are actually interested in laying down their arms? Or is that too much to ask for?

Introducing Commentary Complete

2 Responses to “Killing is Grim Reminder of Stymied Progress in Talks with Taliban”

  1. Vova Khavkin says:

    Obama is negotiating with himself. You have to be delusional to take Taliban negotiations seriously, unless you are a cynical demogogue running for re-election.

  2. No this is not about hope vs. reality , It is about reality Vs EGO. Everyone of these diplomat / State Debt types think they are the next Metternich , they are really only the next Chamberlain . It's all about ego

Leave a Reply