Commentary Magazine


Why Not Sell Weapons to Italy?

I don’t understand the controversy about the administration’s plan to arm with Hellfire missiles and precision-guided bombs six Reaper drones already owned by Italy. Critics contend this would be a dangerous proliferation of American technology. But Italy is one of our closest allies, a stalwart democracy, and a country that is already part of the program to buy the F-35, the second-most-advanced manned fighter aircraft in our arsenal.

There is always a risk that remotely-piloted aircraft owned by Italy could somehow fall into the wrong hands—but that is a risk we run every time we operate those same aircraft over hostile territory. Recall that last December, an RQ-170 stealth drone crashed in Iran, where it was recovered by the authorities. That is one of the risks you take with sophisticated technology. But what’s the alternative? Not employing it at all?

If we expect our allies to carry more of their burden of Western defense then we have to be prepared to sell them the tools to get the job done. In fact, I am mystified that we are not willing to sell the even more sophisticated F-22 to Japan and other close allies. The Reaper drone, while highly effective, isn’t nearly as cutting edge. It is precisely the sort of effective weapons system that will allow our allies to do more to help us.