Commentary Magazine


Contentions

Rubio: Obama Derailed DREAM Act

No surprise here, as killing Sen. Marco Rubio’s proposed DREAM Act was exactly the point of Obama’s announcement on Friday. But it certainly is interesting that the same guy who took to the pages of Time today to urge Congress to pass comprehensive immigration reform is the same guy who has been frantically working behind the scenes to spike Rubio’s legislation. Mission accomplished:

Florida Sen. Marco Rubio said Monday that President Barack Obama’s move last week to block deportations for some young illegal immigrants in the U.S. has likely derailed his own similar efforts, at least until after the election.

“People are going to say to me, ‘Why are we going to need to do anything on this now. It has been dealt with. We can wait until after the election,’” Sen. Rubio said in an interview. “And it is going to be hard to argue against that.”

The conventional wisdom is that Obama pulled some brilliant political footwork, knocking the GOP off message and locking up the Hispanic vote for November. In fact, Obama seems to be the one who was played here, though he may not even realize it. One immigration advocate tells the National Journal that pro-DREAM groups bounced Obama and Rubio off each other, knowing it was going to take some significant political pressure to get the White House to cave on the issue:

“The game changer here was Marco Rubio,’’ said Ali Noorani, executive director of the National Immigration Forum, one of a number of groups that has been pushing the White House on reform. “He was a legitimate conservative trying to find a solution to the broken immigration system … and the administration realized they had to do something.’’

White House sources dismissed the idea that the president acted under pressure from Rubio, saying that the fate of the yet-to-be-filed legislation was unclear. Still, the White House clearly seized the chance to gain the upper hand on the DREAM Act while Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney dithered on whether to back Rubio’s proposal and the senator scrambled to file the legislation.

“The big takeaway from this is that it doesn’t pay to be a friend of Democrats, and it doesn’t pay to be a friend of Republicans,’’ Noorani added. “We were able to ping-pong back and forth between Rubio and the White House.’’

That last paragraph is why Obama’s move may not move the dial with the Hispanic community as much as the White House hopes. Hispanic voters are an increasingly influential voting bloc, but they have often failed to wield this power effectively on a national stage once the elections are over. As a candidate, President Obama promised them the extensive reform, but immediately put immigration issues on the back burner once he took office. It was only when Rubio’s DREAM Act became a threat that Obama jumped into action — but, again, during an election season.

That’s the problem with groups whose votes are taken for granted by one party. Their concerns are often seen as less urgent by the favored party, and the disfavored party has little incentive to act because it won’t get the votes anyway. Immigration advocates seem to realize their agenda won’t progress quickly on a national level unless they have influence with both Republicans and Democrats, and that means they can’t have one party taking Hispanic votes for granted.

Introducing Commentary Complete

6 Responses to “Rubio: Obama Derailed DREAM Act”

  1. mikefoxtrot says:

    Alana, after you finishing trying to balance it on your nose and spin it, the question remains…..will Obama reap political benefit from it or will he not?

  2. Keith_Vlasak says:

    With the MSM spinning it for Obama, I suspect Obama will manage to take a majority of the "Hispanic" bloc, whatever it exactly constitutes. As another Commentary article talks about the Jewish vote in several different states in an attempt to guess about that, I think the Hispanic vote is just as volatile from state to state. In Texas, support for Obama will make no difference. In Florida, isn't what is grouped with Hispanic actually Cuban-Americans who tend to support Reagan style hardliners on Castro? Obama won't lose California. So, I think the Hispanics to wonder about which way they'll lean are those in Arizona and New Mexico specifically??

  3. Keith_Vlasak says:

    Also regarding the Hispanic bloc, an issue I've wondered about and haven't seen any poll or article or any kind of wonder from anyone besides me (and I'm nobody) is if the Obama and black race hatred in the Zimmerman- Martin conflict / trial / black panther hit contract has turned any Hispanics away from voting for Obama brown shirts???

    • Ed Alberts says:

      My take is that (along with the legitimate Mexican Govt concern about F&F) is what led to this. Do not forget that a sizable percentage of the Mexican GNP is folks coming illegally to the US, making their "fortune" and then going back to Mexico or sending it to family there — the Mexican government has long lobbied for amnesty as its citizens working illegally in the US is the pressure relief that keeps their corrupt and ineffective government in power. n nObama is trying to spin this into a "Hate Whitey" coalition and well may – taking folk like La Raza and getting them to hate America more than they hate Blacks., which they do. The problem for Obama is that a lot of the legal immigrants and their children (folk like Michelle Malkin) are going to be incredibly offended and vote "ABO" – Anyone But Obama. n nThe other question is when will this start to legitimize racism again in this country? That in some ways is the scary side of this — "law" now means nothing which means all concept of law well may. n

  4. dougx says:

    Rubio should just say that Obama stole his idea.

  5. Ed Alberts says:

    I think the other side of this is that Rubio lost any chance for a Romney VP pick with this.

Leave a Reply