Commentary Magazine


Contentions

Mitt’s PA Foray No Repeat of McCain Fiasco

Democrats are hoping that the Romney campaign’s decision to invest both time and money in Pennsylvania the last weekend before the election is a sign that the GOP is doomed. Memories of John McCain swooping into the Keystone State four years ago in a futile attempt to gain ground in a state that he would lose by better than 10 percentage points encourages Democrats who believe Romney is making the same mistake. But that was then, and this is now.

Though Romney must still be considered a heavy underdog in Pennsylvania, there’s little doubt that the race has tightened and that a Democratic victory there is no longer a foregone conclusion. Moreover, the Obama camp’s assumption that Romney’s move is rooted in a desperate attempt to craft an Electoral College majority without Ohio may also be dead wrong. Far from conceding the key tossup states to Obama, Romney may be sensing an opportunity to win states few thought he had a chance to take only a few weeks ago.

Conflicting poll numbers in the battleground states have made this one of the most confusing elections in memory. If you believe polls with samples that are disproportionately Democratic then the president seems likely to take Ohio as well as Virginia, virtually closing off any path to 270 Electoral College votes for Romney. But the Romney campaign thinks these numbers are off, since they see little likelihood that the Democrats can conjure up a turnout that will match or even exceed their 2008 hope and change wave that swept Obama into the White House. If, as the Republicans believe, the enthusiastic GOP turnout effort will match that of a Democratic campaign that can’t recapture the spirit of Obama’s first presidential run, Romney is a cinch to win Virginia and has a better-than-even chance in Ohio.

Far from the panic and desperation that characterized the last days of the McCain campaign, the Romney effort right now seems confident not only of winning their share of the tossups but of stealing some blue states on Tuesday. That shone through even in a New York Times story published this morning that reported the shift to the GOP:

But there is a tangible sense — seen in Romney yard signs on the expansive lawns of homes in the well-heeled suburbs, and heard in the excited voices of Republican mothers who make phone calls to voters in their spare time — that the race is tilting toward Mr. Romney.

If ever there were a place where a last-ditch torrent of money could move the needle, this is it. For the last couple of months, there has been a void of presidential ads in Pennsylvania. So when Republican strategists looked for places where their money could go the furthest, they set their sights here, reasoning that a dollar spent in Erie or Altoona would have a greater impact than in a place like Las Vegas or Cleveland, where political commercials have clogged the airwaves.

Despite their bravado, Democrats know Romney is making inroads among women and Jewish voters. Those are demographic groups that fueled Obama’s landslide in Pennsylvania four years ago but which now are deserting him.

Democrats may want to believe that they have Ohio in the bag and that they are in no danger of losing Pennsylvania or Wisconsin, another state where polls show Romney seems to have a real chance. But the decision to have both Romney and runningmate Paul Ryan visit Pennsylvania this weekend seems rooted more in confidence than in a forlorn “Hail Mary” pass to snatch victory from the jaws of defeat. The Republicans may be mistaken in thinking they have any sort of chance in Pennsylvania because of the strength of the Democratic machine in Philadelphia and its still potent ability to manufacture majorities that can outweigh what happens elsewhere in the state. But there is no doubt that state, as well as several others that the Obama campaign had hoped to have wrapped up this late in the game, are still very much in play.

Introducing Commentary Complete

7 Responses to “Mitt’s PA Foray No Repeat of McCain Fiasco”

  1. soccerdhg says:

    Even if Romney can't move PA into his own column, it might help Tom Smith. Which would be helpful to President Romney, should he win.

  2. goon48 says:

    I am thinking that the dems know they're doomed. I wonder what Wednesday will bring…

  3. mike_ste says:

    The Democratic "reasoning" is flat out stupid. I'm not saying Ohio is in the bag for anyone, nor that I think Romney is going to win PA. But, if he thought he was going to lose Ohio – if it was a goner – he wouldn't be in PA. He'd be fortifying the much more likely path to 270 in NH, WI, IA and CO, states which are truly up for grabs. I think the Republicans believe he has a shot in PA and are convinced that all is being done in Ohio that can be done. Besides, last I checked, PA is fairly close to OH, and shares some of the same concerns. Add Smith to the mix, and the whole thing makes sense. Probably not a sign of significant strength or weakness, actually.

  4. aroundthetrack says:

    Who knows how real Romney's chances are in Pennsylvania. My guess is that their private polls show about what the public polls do. The question then is: can a personal visit and saturation advertising make up a four or five point gap for Romney? Several nights ago Hannity had Rasmussen on. When asked about Pennsylvania, he smirked with a slight shake of his head, indicating no. So, if Romney is behind four/five in Pennsylvania, can he pull it off? And why would he forsake valuable time elsewhere for what might be a stretch, albeit a reasonable one? And what effect upon states, like Pennsylvania, will the Obama storm bounce have(see the latest Rasmussen and ABC). So I'll go with my usual pessimistic gut: a useless effort that's not a good sign.

    • soccerdhg says:

      Unless Romney's trying to force Obama to waste resources in PA, so he won't put them to more productive use elsewhere.

    • mike_ste says:

      Maybe, but… nBill Clinton is going to PA, too. I'm pretty sure a week ago you suggested watching the campaigns' actions. I think the fact that Clinton was recently in MN and is now heading to PA, while Romney drew maybe 30K to a rally in OH tonight, is all good news. And don't forget that Obama bought ad time in MI. If it was just Romney heading east, you might have a point, but with all the other pieces of the puzzle, I respectfully disagree.

  5. jmm64 says:

    Get out the vote for Romney , especially in PA, VA, MI, Florida, Ohio, and Wisconsin!!

Leave a Reply