Commentary Magazine


Contentions

Palestinian “Moderates” Rely on Violence

The firing of a single rocket from Gaza today is easy to dismiss as just an isolated incident unworthy of much notice. The rocket was fired at the city of Ashkelon, but fortunately landed in an open field and did not lead to the activation of the Iron Dome defense system. But the attack, which was the first missile launched from Gaza since the cease-fire that ended Operation Pillar of Defense last November, may tell us more about the violent intentions of the so-called moderates of the Palestinians than it does about the Hamas rulers of the strip.

As I noted on Sunday, the Palestinian Authority’s plans to launch a new intifada prior to President Obama’s visit to Israel isn’t exactly a secret. The recent outbreak of violent demonstrations in the West Bank isn’t so much a natural response to anything Israel has done as it is an orchestrated attempt to get the world to focus on Palestinian complaints. Thus it is not exactly a surprise to note that the group that claimed responsibility for today’s rocket wasn’t Hamas or any of its Islamist rivals but the Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigade, which is part of PA leader Mahmoud Abbas’s Fatah party.

The Al Aqsa group’s rocket launch is a reminder to foreign observers that their assumptions about the peaceful intent of Abbas and Fatah is based on willful ignorance and forgetfulness about the last time the PA decided to play the intifada game.

The Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigade, after all, was created by Abbas’s predecessor, Yasir Arafat, in order to compete with Hamas. In the upside-down world of Palestinian politics, a group or a leader’s credibility is based on how many Jews it kills, not how much it can do to help the plight of their people. That’s why genuine moderates like PA Prime Minister Salam Fayyad, who is so well liked in the West, have virtually no constituency.

What may be happening now is, however, a reversal of roles as the PA attempts to bolster its support with violence while Hamas stands pat. Instead of Hamas using terrorism to upstage Fatah in the West Bank, what may be unfolding is a series of events in which it will be the alleged moderates–to whom Israel is being told to make concessions–looking to draw the Islamist rulers of Gaza into a new cycle of violence. The rocket firing was supposedly in retaliation for the death of a Palestinian demonstrator and must be seen in the context of an effort to provoke retaliation that will, they hope, galvanize international condemnation of Israel.

With the West Bank security fence making another campaign of Fatah-funded suicide bombings extremely difficult, and the Iron Dome system making missile attacks on Israel less of a threat, the Palestinians lack effective military options. But they do hope to create enough of a disturbance in order to make President Obama push Israel to do something to appease them. Yet since nothing–not even a settlement freeze–was enough to push Abbas to return to peace talks, there is very little reason for Obama to waste any of his political capital on a spat with Israel that he knows won’t advance the cause of peace.

The last intifada also started with what we were told was a spontaneous outbreak of popular protests, but which were actually instigated by Arafat and followed up with a murderous offensive sponsored by the PA. Fatah may think their interests are best served by heightening tensions with Israel and spilling some blood in order to gain attention. But if they were truly interested in peace or even independence, all they have to do is accept Prime Minister Netanyahu’s offer of peace talks. Until that happens, even an administration as friendly to their cause as that of President Obama is not likely to reward them for inciting violence.

Introducing Commentary Complete

7 Responses to “Palestinian “Moderates” Rely on Violence”

  1. MainesMichael says:

    Abbas deserves the same recognition from Israel that Sheik Yassin received. n n

  2. DansDaMan says:

    "But if they were truly interested in peace or even independence…" n nHere's the problem, Tobin. They're not. So now what?

    • MainesMichael says:

      Jonathan has fallen in to the trap of microanalyzing the differences and nuanced modulations of violence between fatah and hamas, as if a solution can somehow be arrived at if only the right decoding of the shades of meaning can be made and properly responded to. Most everybody's fallen into that good cop bad cop trap called the Peace Process, many Israelis inluded, though to their credit, most of the Israelis know its a fraud, but use it for now as a coping mechanism- and in the meantime life goes on, children are born, grow up, and are happy. n nRidiculous, of course, because when the parties had their chances, they retreated into the usual bloodlusts directed at jews and each other. n nThese parties can not constituionally make peace with Jews or each other or supress their amalekite hatred any more than they can fly unaided. n nAnd we know they can't fly unaided because they didn't fly when they pushed each other's men off of rooftops a few years ago.

  3. watsa46 says:

    The Islamists want violence. The Islamic leaders will continue with violence to remain alive. Those who will renounce the use of violence will become the victim of violence. The Nazi & the Japanese (WWII) did just that and the Muslims will perpetuate this "ritual". nReason is inaccessible to burned out brains. They need to be overpowered one way or another. nThere can't be a "healthy" renaissance without a complete destruction. Germany and Japan are good examples.

  4. @dlataan says:

    The Israelis broke the November 2012 ceasefire the day after it came into effect. Since then the Israelis have broken the ceasefire agreement some 108 times resulting in the deaths of at least four innocent Palestinians and the wounding of at least 91 others. There have been 63 shooting attacks by the Israeli army into the Gaza, 13 incursions into the Gaza by the Israeli army, and 30 attacks on Gaza fisherman by the Israeli navy. All this since the last ceasefire.____ n nTo report that Palestinian fighters have launched an attack against Israel and stating that it is in breach of the ceasefire without mentioning Israel’s violations and thus inferring that the Palestinian attack against Israel is provocation designed to instigate another Intifada is deceitful. The reality is that it has been Israel that has been provoking the Palestinians rather than the other way around. ____ n nPalestinian deaths in custody don’t help either. __

Leave a Reply