Commentary Magazine


Contentions

The European Union’s Misplaced Priorities

In December, I wrote that despite all the misunderstanding and misinformation in the press about Israel’s construction plans for the area around Jerusalem, specifically the E-1 corridor, there was one very illuminating aspect to the controversy. The reaction by Western European leaders and diplomats to the Israeli government’s restatement of the official policy of every Israeli government–right, left, and center–exposed a fault line in EU-Israel relations. The Israeli consensus crosses the EU’s “red line,” and therefore the two are unlikely to find common ground in the peace process.

So it wasn’t much of a surprise to read in the Times of Israel that a new EU report recommends the European Union more actively boycott and sanction Israeli products and companies on the other side of the Green Line. Europe’s growing hostility to Israel and its vast ignorance of Mideast geopolitics are frustrating all by themselves, but a thorough report in the Washington Post today on Hezbollah’s operations in Europe put the EU’s manifest lack of seriousness in stark relief. First, the Times of Israel reports:

In a new report sent to Brussels and foreign ministries in 27 member states, the consuls general representing the EU in the Palestinian territories call on the EU to “prevent, discourage and raise awareness about problematic implications of financial transactions including foreign direct investments, from within the EU in support of settlement activities, infrastructure and services,” Haaretz reported Wednesday.

The EU’s office in Israel declined to directly comment on the leaked document, but diplomats representing EU member states told The Times of Israel on Wednesday that while the report’s language seemed strong, suggesting a call for active EU divestment from the settlements, it signified no actual change in the union’s policy. The 2012 Heads of Mission report, which will be discussed by policymakers in Brussels but is nonbinding, merely calls for stricter implementation of already existing EU legislation, according to a European diplomat.

Contrast the vigilance EU diplomats recommend be employed against Israeli companies with the EU’s continued, exasperating, and fundamentally indefensible reluctance to designate Hezbollah as a terrorist organization. The issue was brought to light again this month as Hezbollah was connected by authorities to last year’s terrorist attack in Bulgaria. Hezbollah has long been among the world’s most resilient and dangerous terrorist organizations, and declaring it as such–as the U.S. and Israel have–would greatly advance security efforts on the continent and would enable increased diligence in tracking and preventing Hezbollah’s funding and communications.

As Joby Warrick writes in the Post, the case of a Hezbollah operative in Cyprus has enabled officials and the public to widen the scope of the terrorist group’s surveillance operations in Europe. And officials are well aware of the implications:

Now, seven months after that attack, new details emerging in Yaakoub’s case are providing chilling insights into what investigators describe as a far broader effort by the Lebanon-based militant group to lay the groundwork for killing Israeli citizens and perhaps others in multiple countries.

Some details have come from Yaakoub himself, who made his first public appearance last week during his trial in Cyprus. But a much fuller account comes from legal documents summarizing the Swedish man’s statements to police during weeks of questioning last summer and obtained by The Washington Post.

The evidence echoes discoveries by investigators in Bulgaria and prosecutors in Thailand, India, Azerbaijan, Kenya and other countries hit by a wave of attempted assassinations and bombings linked to Hezbollah or its chief sponsor, Iran. U.S. officials characterize the plots as part of a shadow war directed by Iran in part to retaliate for Western efforts to derail Iran’s nuclear program. Evidence uncovered by investigators portrays a professional, well-funded effort by Hezbollah to recruit, train and position European-based operatives for what U.S. analysts describe as preparations for future terrorist operations.

It’s important to put the revelations about Hezbollah–which, we can imagine, are not revelations to EU law enforcement and intelligence officials–in the larger context of Hezbollah’s patron, Iran. As Warrick notes, American officials are getting impatient with their European counterparts’ unwillingness to take necessary action against Hezbollah because time is of the essence. The U.S. is working to prevent the Iranians from acquiring nuclear capability, and one element of that has been the stepped-up shadow war between Iran and the West.

In the world of asymmetric warfare, eliminating terrorist safe havens is crucial–as we attempted to do in Afghanistan. But it’s even more important to do so in Europe, both because it’s easier to target Americans and Jews–Iran’s favorite victims–in Europe, where both are far more numerous than in, say, Central Asia or North Africa, and because giving them a safe haven in the West makes it easier to target other Western states. Thus, the EU’s incredibly dangerous actions don’t exist in a vacuum. It’s time for European leaders to stop pretending otherwise.

Introducing Commentary Complete

6 Responses to “The European Union’s Misplaced Priorities”

  1. ahadhaamoratsim says:

    Back in the 1990, a friend's son toured the remains of the death camps with other Jewish high school kids on March of the Living. At one point they were surrounded by a mob of Poles, shoving the kids and shouting threats and insults. The Jews shoved their way through the mob and back to the bus. When they drove off, their Polish guide told the kids it was their own fault for being so visibly Jewish, thereby provoking the Poles. n nAnd that is the long and short of it; to the EU, the very existence of Jews is an unacceptable provocation.

    • MainesMichael says:

      That's unbelievable. What a solid lesson for those kids. n nMy mom, a survivor, went on the March a couple of times as a 'speaker', and fortunately never saw anything like that, but I think she would simply shrug and say 'of course'. n nAs for Seth's piece, above, I would ask when has it ever not been a European priority to harrass or harm Jews in one form or another? n nJust as it used to be said that the sun never set on the British Empire, I would say that at any one time, a Jew or Jews is always being harassed or persecuted somewhere in Europe. It has always been like that, since Constantine's time. n nAfter a brief respite, brought on by WW2 guilt in the Western Europe, and enforced by Communism in East Europe, Europe is reverting to form again vis a vis its relationship to the Jews. n nOh sure, the ostensible reasons and the precise format of the Jew hatred is slightly morphed (in some cases only) to 'anti-Zionism' or 'disagreeing with Israel', but that is cosmetic. But it takes a different form in every generation: n nJews killed Jesus. n nJews poisoned wells and brought on the plague. n nJews baked children's blood into Mazto. n nJews want to control the world. n nJews stole the Palestinians' land and now want to wipe them out.

  2. Empress_Trudy says:

    The supporters of antisemites have it exactly backwards. If there were no Israel for them to hate they'd immediately turn on the Jews still in Europe.

  3. 11bravo says:

    Europe sucks, and their going down the drain. Who cares what they think anymore.r nIf I were isreal, I would say just that with a middle finger in the air.

  4. watsa46 says:

    Seth Mandel has it wrong. Europe was the birth place of antisemitism and remains the most antisemitic "subcontinent" of all. For the Europeans, Jews are the enemy and not the Pal. Above all Europe can't stand the Jews. They dare resist to Christianity, they dare resist Islam, they are at the top of many "human activities" in Europe, in North-America and probably in many countries of Central and South-America., etc… .Europe defeated the Muslims several times, they tried to eliminate the Jews and failed so they continue where they stopped in 1945. The vast majority of European Jews are in fear; in the US people do not care and are not aware. Remember that Americans are self-centered too. So, there are a lot of false and fabricated excuses to hate the Jews. The simple fact is that a lot of people in the West and the Muslim world are simply JEALOUS. This explains everything while justifying nothing. The Jews were suppose to fail in Israel and disappear and they are succeeding beyond and against any expectations. That in itself is another cause for rage. This goes on and on and on … nDeja vu!

  5. besht2003 says:

    Israel should build an underground uranium processing plant in E-1. For medical isotope research of couse.

Leave a Reply