Commentary Magazine


Contentions

Detroit at Bay

Governor Rick Snyder of Michigan announced today that he will be appointing an emergency manager to oversee Detroit, which is bankrupt in every way but officially. Its liabilities exceed $14 billion and it is short of cash just to meet current obligations. As Governor Snyder expressed it at a town hall meeting today, “The way I view it, today is a day to call all hands on deck.”

The urban disaster that is today’s Detroit is almost beyond imagination. Just compare it to Hiroshima. In 1945, the latter was flattened by an atomic bomb and Detroit was the fourth largest city in the United States, with a population of over 1.8 million, the center of its largest and most powerful industry. Today, Hiroshima is a gleaming, modern city and Detroit has a population of 706,585 and ranks 18th, behind such cities as Indianapolis, Columbus, Ohio, and Charlotte, North Carolina. Long the arson capital of the United States, whole neighborhoods are now barren wastelands.

To be sure, the suburbanization of America beginning after World War II has not been kind to the nation’s older cities. Indeed, every city in the country that had a major league baseball team in 1950, which is to say the largest cities in the northeast quadrant of the country, has seen a marked decline in population, with the exception of New York (always the exception). But many of those cities are now bouncing back. Not Detroit. Led by a kleptocracy in league with municipal unions, Detroit continues to hemorrhage population, wealth, and quality of life. It didn’t take an atomic bomb to destroy Detroit. Mayors such as Coleman Young and Kwame Kilpatrick were quite enough.

As the New York Times reports:

The state-appointed manager, who could be selected later this month, would ultimately wield powers aimed at swiftly turning around the municipal government’s dire circumstances — powers to cut city spending, change contracts with labor unions, merge or eliminate city departments, urge the sale of city assets and even, if all else failed, to recommend bankruptcy proceedings.

Because Detroit is the creature of the sovereign state of Michigan, the governor has the power to impose such discipline, whether Detroit’s government likes it or not (needless to say it doesn’t). What a pity no one has the power to impose it on Washington D.C.

Introducing Commentary Complete

3 Responses to “Detroit at Bay”

  1. nvkma says:

    Detroit’s population is706,585, and its liabilities exceed $14 billion. That works out to $19,813 per Detroit citizen. That’s bad; but compare this to the maga-mess that our nation is in, largely ignored by the Mendacious Sellout Media that stopped looking out for our country decades ago: n nThe US Population = 315M n nThe US National debt = $16.6 ($52,677 per citizen) n nThe US unfunded liabilities = $122.9T ($1.087M per citizen) n nThe Total Personal Debt = $15.7T ($49.972 per citizen) n nWe, as a nation, are in worse shape than than Detroit on every count.

  2. rulieg says:

    you've left out a crucial reason for Detroit's plight, and that is race. and I'm not talking about the fact that Detroit is a majority black city now. so is Atlanta; big difference! n nI live just 40 miles down I-94, in Ann Arbor. we've watched for years as the nearly-all-black Detroit city government has resisted any "outside intervention" to slow down the city's death throes. people like the disgraceful Monica Conyers and that corrupt weasel of a mayor Kwame Kilpatrick are reelected time after time, the main qualification being the perception that they're "standing up to the man." n nthis emergency manager thing is totally being spun in the local papers as yet another instance of the white guys up in Lansing trying to take over We The People in Detroit. these clueless Detroit officials don't seem to understand their city is dying, and that something drastic needs to happen or everybody's going to lose. n nI should note that current mayor Dave Bing is a good guy, and an honest man. but Detroit is too far gone at this point for even a good guy to save all by himself.

  3. misternatural13 says:

    and we're supposed to surprised? nare we surprised by zimbabwe?

Leave a Reply