Commentary Magazine


Contentions

Why is the U.S. Honoring Hugo Chavez?

If the Chavistas currently running Venezuela have their way, the cult of Hugo Chavez will be even more overwhelming after his death than during his life. This morning, as the country prepared for the grand state funeral of Chavez, Vice President Nicolas Maduro announced that the late President’s cadaver would be embalmed and placed on permanent display in a Caracas museum.

“It has been decided that the body of the comandante will be embalmed so that it remains eternally on view for the people,” Maduro said. “Like Ho Chi Minh, like Lenin, like Mao Zedong. The body of our commander in chief, embalmed in the museum of the revolution, in a special way so he can be in a glass case and our people can have him there present always.”

In citing these precedents, Maduro unwittingly undermined those many voices that have, over the course of this week, eulogized Chavez as, variously, a social reformer, a civil rights activist, and a tribune of popular democracy. Any genuine democrat would flinch at the thought of being compared to China’s Mao, who is estimated to have starved, beaten and shot between 40 and 60 million of his own people. But Chavez was not such a leader, and his successors have left no doubts over their fealty to the 20th century’s most murderous political currents.

Among the foreign leaders and dignitaries attending Chavez’s funeral are three United States representatives, Rep. Gregory Meeks (D-NY), former Massachusetts Congressman Bill Delahunt, and Charge d’Affaires James Derham (currently, there is no U.S. ambassador in Caracas, since Chavez rejected the Obama Administration’s nominee for the post, Larry Palmer, in 2010). It’s safe to assume that they won’t be included among the “A” List of those present; that privilege is reserved for individuals like Alexander Lukashenko, president of Europe’s last dictatorship, Belarus; the Cuban leader Raul Castro, who has spent the last three months running the Venezuelan government from Havana; and Iran’s outgoing President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, who outdid even Maduro by proclaiming that Chavez would “return to Earth” together with Jesus and the Twelfth Imam.

By giving its official seal of approval to the mourning period for Chavez, the Obama administration is hoping that this goodwill gesture will enable a “reset”–there’s that word again–of its relations with Venezuela. But the Chavistas will have a different interpretation; namely, that the U.S. has resigned itself to the permanency of Chavez’s ” Bolivarian” revolution, and the continued centrality of the ideology of chavismo in Venezuela’s affairs.

As Mary Anastasia O’Grady observed in the Wall Street Journal, “[T]here may not be much the Free World can do to help Venezuela rid itself of the terrible scourge known as chavismo.” But, she added, “at a minimum, it could refuse to go along with the charade that the country is still a democracy with free elections. Repeating the lie doesn’t make it any truer.”

What facts does that charade obscure? Back in December, I pointed out that under Chavez, there was no longer a constitutional separation of powers in Venezuela. Key institutions like the National Electoral Commission, which runs the electoral process, and PDVSA, the state-owned oil company that has squandered billions of dollars in revenue on oil subsidies for Cuba, remain in the hands of loyal Chavistas. The country’s Supreme Court is packed with judges personally appointed by Chavez, while the present prosecutor-general, Cilia Flores, is married to Maduro.

Arguably the most important transformation of the Chavez years concerns the armed forces. Indeed, and in violation of the country’s constitution, the armed forces can reasonably be said to be running the country. Twelve out of the country’s 23 state governors are former military men. Several of the government ministers who will be publicly grieving for the Comandante today were involved in Chavez’s failed coup attempt in 1992 against a democratically elected government. Most grotesquely, the country’s defense minister, Admiral Diego Molero, has said that the military will back Maduro’s presidential candidacy, in flagrant violation of the ban on the military’s involvement in politics.

Against this reality, the United States should have boycotted Chavez’s funeral. By sending a delegation instead, Washington is helping to maintain the fiction that any future election in Venezuela will be more or less fair.

Still, now that our representatives have arrived in Caracas, there is one useful thing they can do. After paying their respects to Chavez, they should go and see Maria Lourdes Afiuni, one of the last remaining independent judges in Venezuela, who was incarcerated in 2009 as punishment for ending the pre-trial detention of a banker, Elegio Cedeno, who ran afoul of the Chavez regime.

While in prison, credible reports surfaced of Afiuni–dubbed by Chavez as a “bandit”–being harassed, beaten and even raped. She is now under house arrest. By visiting her and giving her case some much needed publicity, the American delegation could salvage some dignity from today’s circus.

Introducing Commentary Complete

16 Responses to “Why is the U.S. Honoring Hugo Chavez?”

  1. goon48 says:

    Because the president and his administration are idiots.

    • GangOfOne says:

      Goon, this POTUS and his Admin can't help themselves. They are not even crypto-Communists at this point; they are in bed with every America-hating, anti-Capitalist regime. That they are not fawning over Kim Chi #3 lends them only so much credibility.

  2. mike_ste says:

    Yeah – just another populist caudillo who plunged his country into misery while committing numerous human rights atrocities. Ho-hum, nothing to see here. After all, history has given us worse! Ergo, "diplomacy" requires an American presence at his rather grotesque funeral. nEver wonder why so many Poles love Reagan? (I enjoyed some time in a giant park named for him in Gdansk a few years ago, and will again this summer.) He knew when NOT to play that stupid, cynical game. I think the absence of a few American nonentities from Venezuela in the next few days would do more "resetting" with Venezuela (and elsewhere) than will their presence.

  3. Empress_Trudy says:

    The upside is that without the charisma of il Duce, his flying monkeys will continue to drive the country straight into the ground but they won't be able to manage the clever dance il Duce pulled off through a combination of payoffs, propaganda, threats, mob violence and such it takes to hold the country together. There is no external enemy and most of the internal enemies are pretty civilized so the odds are that Venezuela don't really end in chaos so much as it merely grinds to a halt. Violence, bad economy, terrible management, terrible industrial safety, total reliance on oil w/o any investment in it. It will turn into yet another banana republic police state teetering on the edge of the third world, led by thugs who are busy stealing everything they can.

  4. Ridiculous. Diplomacy requires diplomatic courtesy. Doesn't mean we love the man. In any case, whatever his faults, he was no Stalin or Mao. Just another populist caudillo. n nTake a deep breath. Maybe ten.

  5. vandag1 says:

    For at least a week. Now I would GLADLY go to his funeral – and I wouldn't be 'Grumpy', but joyful. But it is best to ignore the idiot and just hit thumbs down without injuring your eyeballs.

    • Thanks to mike_ste for responding substantively to my points. n nAs for those who wish for my death, you will get your wish sooner or later. Whether your remarks are persuasive, I leave to the reader.

  6. KimBatteau says:

    Maduro's stunning statement is making the left in the U.S. cringe: “Like Ho Chi Minh, like Lenin, like Mao Zedong. The body of our commander in chief, embalmed in the museum of the revolution, in a special way so he can be in a glass case and our people can have him there present always.” Let us never forget these revealing words!

    • Controse says:

      Ah, a Mao Zedong wannabe. Now that is something to aspire to. Joining that august pantheon of mass murders would be ennobling for his memory so says his replacement.

    • nvkma says:

      I think for a lot Venezuelans it may comforting to occasionally go to see the corpse and enjoy its present state of repose and then go to a nightclub with lots of singing, dancing and drinking.

    • ldubinsky says:

      Maduro makes most any sane person cringe as his statements are loathsome, third-rate garbage.

      • ahadhaamoratsim says:

        Any sane person – yes. The leadership of the US State Department – apparently not so much.

      • ldubinsky says:

        the job of the State Department is to engage in diplomacy and gather info, aha, not to join me in expressing disgust. n n

  7. ldubinsky says:

    bullshift contention. The USA isn't honoring Chavez any more than it's endorsing this worthless pile from Cohen.

Leave a Reply