In response to Shmuel Rosner’s post on James Baker’s belief that both Bill Clinton and George W. Bush “waited too long” to tackle the Arab-Israeli issue, Emanuele Ottolenghi listed everything Clinton facilitated from 1993 through 2000, including: the ceremony on the White House lawn, the Cairo Agreement, the Washington Declaration, the Jordan-Israel peace agreement, the Oslo-II agreement, the Wye Accord, the Camp David Summit, and the Clinton Parameters.

The seven-year Clinton “peace process” ended with the Palestinians rejecting the Camp David offer of a state, starting a new terror war, and declining the last best offer in the Clinton Parameters. On January 20, 2001, George W. Bush inherited a war already in its fourth month and an Israeli electorate that within two weeks dismissed Ehud Barak in a landslide election. Dennis Ross retired to write an 800-page book to explain how the process did not work out as planned.

Far from ignoring the Arab-Israeli issue, Bush did the following: (1) became in 2002 the first U.S. president to endorse a Palestinian state as a matter of official policy; (2) translated the policy in 2003 into a Road Map approved by the UN, the EU, Russia, the Palestinian Authority and Israel; (3) negotiated with Israel in 2004 on the Gaza Disengagement Deal (and got West Bank settlements dismantled to demonstrate it would not stop with Gaza); (4) supported a Palestinian election in 2005 to endorse a new leader pledged to dismantling terrorist groups; (5) permitted all parties to participate in the 2006 elections to give Palestinians a choice between the “peace partner” party and the premier terrorist group; (6) scuttled the first two phases of the Road Map in 2007, in order to keep the process going, even after the Palestinians elected their premier terrorist group; (7) convened a worldwide conference in Annapolis in 2007 to begin a year-long period of final status negotiations; and (8) had his Secretary of State make umpteen trips in 2006-2008 to push the negotiations.

And Bush ended up exactly where Clinton did: with another seven-year “process” culminating in a Palestinian refusal to accept a contiguous state, on substantially all of the West Bank and Gaza, unless Israel accepted the “right of return” and a re-divided Jerusalem along the 1967 line. During the entire 14-year process, not a single terrorist organization was dismantled. The problem was most certainly not U.S. presidents who “waited too long.”

del.icio.us

Google

Facebook

This entry was posted on Tuesday, December 9th, 2008 at 10:45 AM and is filed under Contentions. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.