X

Email Address:

Password:

Forgot password?
OK

Commentary

Sign In | Home | Customer Service | About Us | Advertise
PRINT SUBSCRIBERS: REGISTER FOR ONLINE ACCESS

advanced search
  • Subscribe
  • Give a Gift
  • Renew
  • Register Online
  • Customer Service
  • Back Issues
  • Buy Articles
  • Donate
    1. Obama and Race
      Linda Chavez
      June 2008
    2. Gandhi and Churchill by Arthur Herman
      Mark Falcoff
      June 2008
    3. 1948, Israel, and the Palestinians: Annotated Text
      Efraim Karsh
    4. 1948, Israel, and the Palestinians—
      The True Story

      Efraim Karsh
      May 2008
    5. Land That I Love
      Joseph I. Lieberman
  1. Obama and Race
    Linda Chavez
    June 2008
  2. Gandhi and Churchill by Arthur Herman
    Mark Falcoff
    June 2008
  3. What Does Reform Judaism Stand For?
    Jack Wertheimer
    June 2008
  4. 1948, Israel, and the Palestinians: Annotated Text
    Efraim Karsh
  5. 1948, Israel, and the Palestinians—
    The True Story

    Efraim Karsh
    May 2008

Advertisement

Advertisement

contensions.jpg
about us | contact us | archive | contributors | subscribe to commentary | advertise | RSS
commentary's blogs: the horizon | contentions | connecting the dots
« Japan Leaves the War on Terror
"Intraparty Democracy"? »

An Act of Kindness from Iraq

Michael J. Totten - 10.29.2007 - 12:31 PM

Iraqi Army officers in Besmaya raised a thousand dollars in donations for fire victims in San Diego, California, and the only place that seems to have reported the story is the military blog OPFOR. Author Richard S. Lowry learned about it in a press release from the Multi-National Security Transition Command-Iraq Public Affairs, so it’s unlikely he’s the only one in the media who knows something about it.

Sending a thousand dollars to California will be about as helpful as throwing a glass of water into the firestorm. It’s the thought that counts here. And what surprising thought it is. How many Americans expect charity from Iraq?

As Lowry points out, “most Americans do not consider Iraqis as people.” He’s right. Most of us only know them from sensational media reports about masked insurgents, wailing widows, and death squads. Most of us may instinctively understand that the majority of Iraqis are just regular people, but it’s hard to keep that in mind when the only thing we get Stateside is war coverage. I’ve met hundreds of Iraqis myself during trips to their country as a reporter, so it’s a bit easier for me to see them as just people. I’m still surprised that anyone in that broken impoverished land would even consider donating hard-earned money to Californians.

A thousand dollars is a lot in Iraq. The average salary is only a few hundred dollars a month. I can’t for the life of me figure out how entire families can survive on so little, considering most have so many children. Basic necessities are cheaper in Iraq than in the West, but not that much cheaper.

Some Iraqis have been learning a similar lesson about American generosity lately.

Two months ago I went on a humanitarian aid drop mission outside Ramadi, the capital of Iraq’s Anbar Province, with American soldiers and Iraqi Police officers at four o’clock in the morning. The goods we delivered were paid for by the United States government. Sometimes, though, soldiers and Marines deliver items donated through American charities. “When we tell them that some of these packages aren’t from the military or the government,” a Marine told me, “that they were donated by average American citizens in places like Kansas, people choke up and sometimes even cry. They just can’t comprehend it. It is so different from the lies they were told about us and how we’re supposed to be evil.”

Sustained contact with the “other” isn’t a magic bullet against bigoted attitudes (see, for example, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict), but it usually helps. Iraqis learn about Americans through daily interactions, but most Americans have no contact, sustained or otherwise, with Iraqis.

Shopkeeper Was Nice to Embedded Reporter isn’t a headline, but donations from Besmaya to San Diego is a real story. Now would be a good time for major newspapers, as well as blogs and magazines like this one, to show Iraqis, for once, as generous and regular people.

UPDATE: CNN now has the story on their Web site. Good for them.

»Back to Contentions »Back to Commentary

del.icio.us del.icio.us
Google Google
Facebook Facebook
Email This Post Print This Post Permanent Link To Article


This entry was posted on Monday, October 29th, 2007 at 12:31 PM and is filed under Contentions. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

7 Responses to “An Act of Kindness from Iraq”

  1. 1
    michael knepper Says:
    October 29th, 2007 at 2:14 PM

    I thought this was an interesting article. Personally, I have always seen Iraqis as normal people in a horrendous situation. They are a strong and brave people that have endured hardships that most of the Western world can not begin to comprehend. This article represents what has saddened me most about the Western media. They never report on the Iraqi people and the good work done by so many organizations in that country (Iraqi and non-Iraqi). It seems that the old addage of journalism is true. “If it bleeds it leads”. I hope that this article and others like it make it to the main stream media. Then America will get to see the Iraqi people as they are. I do not hold out a lot of hope though. I read every article I can find that Mr.Totten writes. I am a fan of what he does and hopes that he continues what I believe to be great work.

  2. 2
    Roy Lofquist Says:
    October 29th, 2007 at 6:18 PM

    CNN had a lengthy feature on this story in the 1:00-2:00 PM segment today, including a live interview with an Army colonel. It was really quite encouraging with the CNN person very enthusiastic about it.

  3. 3
    mike d Says:
    October 29th, 2007 at 6:26 PM

    Method of discerning if this story would ever make it to a major daily or network news broadcast:

    Is there a way to blame either the Bush administration, American troops or the allied mission generally for the crux of the story? No.

    Is there a global warming angle?
    No.

    Does it help Hillary?
    No.

    Would readers or viewers be inclined to consider the story as positive news coming out of Iraq suggesting that not all the troops are bloodthirsty redneck rapists and murderers of
    peace-loving, kite-flying Iraqis?
    Very Likely.

    And there’s your answer.

  4. 4
    joyce Says:
    October 29th, 2007 at 8:51 PM

    Thank you, Iraq. We appreciate your thoughtfulness. I forwarded the article to all media hosts (radio and TV).

  5. 5
    crosspatch Says:
    October 30th, 2007 at 2:24 AM

    I wish there was some way I could acknowledge their generosity and thank them for their gift. I wasn’t burned out of my home and the money won’t go to help me, but the fact that they were thinking of us here in America should, in my opinion, be recognized and responded to. At least enough to let them know that we noticed.

  6. 6
    Jack Hyde Says:
    October 30th, 2007 at 5:10 PM

    It is nice to know that the war is finally over, that many Iraqis have decide to join the free world and to take on all the responsibility that entails.

  7. 7
    shema toyota Says:
    January 20th, 2008 at 10:34 PM

    toyota ekspluataciya toyota rukovodstvo toyota cena toyota centr shema toyota oficialnyy diler toyota novaya toyota corolla avtosalony toyota kuzova toyota

Leave a Reply

Advertisement

image of latest cover
image of latest cover

FREE SAMPLE ISSUE

  • the complete archive
  • hundreds of authors
  • thousands of articles
  • American history
    since 1945

ENTER THE ARCHIVE

ADVERTISER LINKS

Illustrations by Terry Colon
Secured Loans
Used Cars
Car Loans
Car Finance by Location
Car Finance
Bad Car Credit
Debt Management
Used Cars
Concert Tickets 
Compare Secured Loans
Life Insurance
Boat Hire
Secured Loans



Advertisement


Advertisement

Commentary is proudly powered by WordPress
Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS).



Home | Subscribe | About Us | Donate | Advertise | Contact Us | Legal Notices | RSS

Commentar

Copyright © 1997-2008 Commentary Magazine
All Rights Reserved