xTooltipElement
    1. Obama's Enemies List
      Peter Wehner
    2. Islamist Extremism and the Murder of Daniel Pearl
      Joseph I. Lieberman
    3. Why Obama Is Wrong on Missile Defense
      Steven Price
    4. How Politics Destroyed a Great TV Show
      Jonah Goldberg
      October 2009
    5. Why Are Jews Liberals?—A Symposium
      David Wolpe, Jonathan D. Sarna, Michael Medved, William Kristol and Jeff Jacoby
      September 2009

Advertisement



1949
View: All Months | Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec

 January, 1949

Europe's Democracy and “American Imperialism”:
Despite Truman's Election the Fear Persists

George Lichtheim

Any inquiry into the present state of relations between progressives in Britain and in the United States must start with the recent presidential election.

Does the Jew Exist?
Sartre's Morality Play About Anti-Semitism

Harold Rosenberg

In Considering Sartre's conception of the Jew and his relation to anti-Semitism we must not forget that Reflections on the Jewish Question (published by Schocken as Anti-Semite and Jew) was written immediately after the downfall of the Nazis. It was a moment of intense confusion as to the meaning of the terrible events that had just taken place and of uncertainty as to the attitudes and groupings that would now emerge in liberated France. The Occupation had enlivened the current of anti-Semitism among Frenchmen of all classes. With the return of those Jews who had escaped the German hangman everyone was most anxious that this “question” should not once more stir up hidden rancors. Thus, as Sartre tells us, in the midst of the general greeting of returned prisoners and deportees not a word about the Jews, for fear of irritating the anti-Semites. This testimony is supported by André Spire's account, in his preface to Bilan Juif, of the difficulties experienced in finding a publisher in Paris by those who wished to speak of what had happened. “There has been too much hate,” they were told. “Let's have a love story.”

The “Joint” Takes a Human Inventory:
The End of the DP Problem Is in Sight

Hal Lehrman

With the State of Israel an accomplished fact and the peak of the overseas emergency relief program now passed, the Joint Distribution Committee has felt the need to take stock as of 1948, to review the past and weigh the future.

Secret Jews of Persia:
A Century-Old Marrano Community in Asia

Walter J. Fischel

Of the sixty thousand Jews in Persia, most live in the large cities—Teheran, Hamadan, and others—with smaller groups in many towns and villages.

The Poetry of Isaac Rosenberg:
“Sudden the Lightning Flashed Upon a Figure. . . .”

Marius Bewley

When Isaac Rosenberg was buried in an unmarked grave in France in 1918, he left behind only a slender sheaf of poetry that can be regarded as really important.

Moby Dick:
A Reflection

Earl Hendler

A Poem.

UN Breathing Spell on Palestine:
A New Phase, But the Old Problems Remain

Robert Weltsch

The establishment of an innocuous Conciliation Commission by the UN Assembly, with practically no terms of reference (even to its own partition decision of November 29, 1947), marked the abandonment of Count Bernadotte's plan.

Modern Artist as Synagogue Builder:
Satisfying the Needs of Today's Congregations

Percival and Paul Goodman

Of all branches of culture, the plastic arts have been the last to be cultivated by modem Jews.

The Time My Grandfather Died
A Story

Wolf Mankowitz

A Story.

From the American Scene: The Fleshpots of Maine

Toby Shafter

Although my home town is considered of average size for the state of Maine (population 9,000), I must in all truth admit that it is only another seacoast village masquerading as a metropolis.

Cedars of Lebanon: Reason and Faith

Saadya Gaon

After this brief opening in praise and eulogy of our Lord, I will begin this book . . .

On the Horizon: The Decent German: Film Portrait

Siegfried Kracauer

Within the last few months, several German postwar films have come to us from the Soviet zone of occupation.

On the Horizon: Starring Schwartz and Skulnik

Heinz Politzer

It is characteristic of the paradoxical situation in which present-day Jewish culture finds itself that the play with which Maurice Schwartz opened the season of his Yiddish Art Theatre in New York attempted what the Hebrew state theater, Habimah, has so far failed to do.

The Study of Man: Comic Books and Other Horrors

Norbert Muhlen

Crime is entertainment, and murder a Parlor game,” Viscount Samuel recently said of our times in an address before the British Association for the Advancement of Science.

Cloak-and-Dagger Dept.

Reader Letters

Brandeis and Holmes

Reader Letters

Advance Intelligence

Reader Letters

Thanks, But—

Reader Letters

One Man's Meat

Reader Letters

A Point of Kashruth

Reader Letters

On Commentary

Reader Letters

Benya Krik the Gangster, by Isaak Babel

Reviewed by John Berryman

Seven Books on the Negro in America

Reviewed by James Baldwin

 February, 1949

Can Western Civilization Save Itself?
Our Present Anxiety in the Light of History

Arnold J. Toynbee

I fancy it is a rather new idea to think of looking at current affairs in the light of history, at all events remote history.

Dictator of the Lodz Ghetto
The Strange History of Mordechai Chaim Rumkowski

Solomon F. Bloom

A few years ago a tremendous and extraordinary catastrophe struck the Jewish people.

The Segregation Threat in Housing:
Can We Plan for Democratic Neighborhoods?

Charles Abrams

The cause of racial equality has won some impressive victories in recent years.

The Jewish Spirit Among the Nations:
Judaism Never Flourished in National Isolation

Leo S. Baeck

Every nation, even if surrounded by deserts or dividing seas, knows of other nations, and its gaze is again and again drawn towards them, willingly or unwillingly.

Austria: Rebuilding in a Volcano:
Progress Report, with Reservations

G. E. R.

John Foster Dulles is only the latest of a number of expert eye-witnesses to be impressed by Austria's economic recovery and growing political stability.

Cross-Currents in Arab National Feeling:
The Islamic World is Shaken by Modern Tensions

S. D. Goitein

It was not until after World War I that the Arabs became conscious of themselves as a people.

The Arabs' Peculiar “Anti-Semitism”:
An Old Hostility Takes a New Form

From recent events, we know that the Arab holds an attitude of hostility to the Jew strong enough to produce political impasse and war, together with sporadic pogroms in the Arab countries.

Moving-Picture Show

Milton Kaplan

A Poem.

From the American Scene:“Kochalein”: Poor Man's Shangri-La

Harry Gersh

In the good old days when my great-uncle Zissel came to America (circa 1904) the word “fix” had two distinct meanings.

Cedars of Lebanon: Talmudic Proverbs

Proverbs by Rav Nahman.

On the Horizon: A Year of Jewish Music

Kurt List

Jewish musical life in New York in the past season did not differ markedly from that of the previous one.

The Study of Man: The Downward Trend of Jewish Population

L. Hersch

Discussions of the Jewish future: of the Jewish religion, of Jewish culture, of the new Jewish state, become ever more subtle and complex.

German and Jew

Reader Letters

Left Zionism

Reader Letters

Violence in the Comics

Reader Letters

An Act of Love, by Ira Wolfert

Reviewed by Isa Kapp

 March, 1949

America's Un-Marxist Revolution:
Mr. Truman Embarks on a Politically Managed Economy

Daniel Bell

After a decade and a half, an adequate political characterization of the New Deal era is still to be written.

The Black Jews of Ethiopia:
An Expedition to the Falashas

Wolf Leslau

In 1946 I undertook a scientific expedition, under the joint auspices of the Guggenheim Foundation and the Viking Fund, to study the languages, folklore, and traditional history of Ethiopia.

Heinrich Heine: Flight and Return:
The Fallacy of Being Only a Human Being

Martin Greenberg

In the 2nd century BCE, after the world triumph of Hellenic culture under Alexander the Great, we come upon Jews in Jerusalem who, in addition to Hellenizing their names, underwent a painful operation to efface the marks of their circumcision.

The Rebirth of the Italian People:
Peasant and City Man Join in a New Democracy

Carlo Levi

Italian life has that ambiguity peculiar to things alive and beautiful.

Anti-Semitic Stereotypes in Zionism:
The Nationalist Rejection of Diaspora Jewry

Yehezkel Kaufman

It is customary to define the word “anti-Semitism” as “hatred of Jews,” but this definition is not accurate.

Behind Bevin's Hostility to Israel:
Britain is Not Yet Reconciled to the Realities

George Lichtheim

“What now confronts us is the task of readjusting our Middle Eastern policy to the new realities."

The End of Sergei Eisenstein:
Case History of an Artist under Dictatorship

Waclaw Solski

In 1925 I was working for the Sovkino in Moscow, having come to Russia shortly before as an adviser on movie production for the foreign market.

The Girl Who Loved Seders
A Story

Ralph Manheim

A Story.

The Bride

Hyman Swetzoff

A Poem.

From the American Scene: An Orthodox G.I. Fights a War

Gottfried Neuburger

It started at once, in the improvised mess hall in the crowded induction center in Grand Central Palace.

Cedars of Lebanon: To America!

Leopold Kompert

And we are not saved! The sun of freedom has risen for our fatherland, but for us it is only the bloody light of the North.

On the Horizon: “Gentleman's Agreement” Abroad

Benno Weiser

Hablan todo el tiempo de judios—All they talk about is the Jews,” said the man who walked out before the movie was over.

On the Horizon: Jewish Culture in Western Europe

David Scheinert

What is the situation of Jewish culture in Europe since the war?

The Study of Man: Food or Famine?

James Rorty

Is it possible to determine, with even a rough approximation of accuracy, the position of contemporary man in the muddy turbulence of half-understood forces that shape his environment—that shifting complex of soil and water, plant, animal, and mineral wealth, human use and misuse?

What Kind of Synagogue?

Reader Letters

The Comics Controversy

Reader Letters

On This Side Nothing, by Alex Comfort

Reviewed by George Becker

The Alphabet, by David Diringer

Reviewed by Theodor Gaster

Power and Personality, by Harold D. Lasswell

Reviewed by Dennis H. Wrong

The Protestant Era, by Paul Tillich

Reviewed by Irving Kristol

 April, 1949

Does Democracy Need Nazi Partners?
The Dangerous Course of Our German Reconstruction

Nicolas Clarion

The democracies have apparently won the “battle of Berlin.”

The Yeshiva Comes to Westchester:
The Legalistic Hedges of Suburbia

Herrymon Maurer

It would be easy to tell this story of the confrontation of the Yeshiva of Nitra and a top-drawer Westchester County township in the light irony of the current British film comedies of suburbia.

Jewish Life in the Russian Satellites:
The Prospects for Recovery under Totalitarianism

Nathan Reich

By now the future of two segments of the 1,500,000 European Jews who survived World War II (outside of Russia) can be charted with reasonable accuracy; the fate of the third, those living in the Soviet satellites, still hangs in the balance.

Broadway and American Integrity:
The Lost Souls that People our Stage

Alfred Kazin

Broadway is not usually thought of as the keeper of America's conscience, but among the serious American plays this season a favorite theme has been the American struggle for integrity.

What Price Israel's “Normalcy”?
A Young Nation and its Ideals

Ernst Simon

Even a superficial observer might notice the three traits in Israel's Jewish youth that still strike me as fundamental after twenty years of experience.

Thomas Mann's “Doctor Faustus”:
“Terminal Work” of an Art Form and an Era

Erich Kahler

The great novels of the 20th century, its essential books, are without exception terminal books, apotheoses of the narrative form.

Self-Portrait of a 17th-Century Housewife:
The Memoirs of Glückel of Hameln

David Scheinert

In 1690, at the age of forty-four, about a year after the death of her husband, Glückel of Hameln began the writing of what is as much a ledger as the “memoirs of her life.”

The Badge
A Story

Robert Misrahi

I wish I had a new suit to sew it on. This one's all shabby and the patch on the right-hand pocket stands out too much.

From the American Scene: My Grandmother Had Yichus

May Natalie Tabak

Aladdin had a lamp, the Rothschilds had money, someone's uncle had a candy store—my grandmother had yichus.

Cedars of Lebanon: Moses the Prophet

Henry George

Each recurring year brings a day on which, in every land, there are men who, gathering about them their families, and attired as if for a journey, eat with solemnity a hurried meal.

On the Horizon: Opening Game in Zion

William Schack

One June day in 1927 the Americans in Jerusalem, hitherto outwardly respectable, were seen making their way to the open spaces of the city wearing common caps, old pants, and abraded shoes.

On the Horizon: The True Source of Jewish Music

Eric Werner

The controversy between traditionalism and modernism in Jewish liturgical music has in the last three or four years stirred many pens.

The Study of Man: New Paths in American Jewish History

Oscar Handlin

The low status of writing in American Jewish history has been an open secret for two decades or more, but only recently has dissatisfaction become general and vocal.

Today's the Day

Earl Hendler

A Poem.

Yiddish, But Is It Art?

Reader Letters

American Falashas?

Reader Letters

The Double Gift

Reader Letters

Segregation in Housing

Reader Letters

Eimi, by E. E. Cummings

Reviewed by Raymond Rosenthal

Among the Nations, edited by Ludwig Lewisohn

Reviewed by Irving A. Sanes

Man for Himself, by Erich Fromm

Reviewed by Lillian Blumberg

 May, 1949

What Can We Do About Fagin?
The Jew-Villain in Western Tradition

Leslie A. Fiedler

“Since the Diaspora, and the scattering of the Jews amongst peoples holding the Christian Faith,” T. S. Eliot writes in an incidental footnote in Towards a Definition of Culture, “it may have been unfortunate both for these peoples and for the Jews themselves, that the culture-contact between them has had to be within those neutral zones of culture in which religion could be ignored. . . .”

Departure and Arrival:Embarkation to Israel

Robert and Martha Levin

For two months my wife and I had been bicycling through France, cut off from the world.

Departure and Arrival:Family Reunion in the Land

Juliette Pary

For hours I have been wandering through the port of Haifa, under the broiling sun, looking for an obscure address; finally I meet a passerby who knows his way around.

Marx's Prophecy in the Light of History:
Balance Sheet After a Century

Franz Borkenau

Marxism presents itself as a science capable of practical application.

Pleasure Island

W. H. Auden

A Poem.

Eichmann: Administrator of Extermination:
“The Definitive Solution of the Jewish Problem”

L. Poliakov

Hitler's pronouncements on the “Jewish question” were generally regarded as the fantasies of a disordered mind.

Has Judaism Still Power to Speak?
A Religion for an Age of Crisis

Will Herberg

The revival of creative theological thinking is generally recognized as one of the significant events in recent intellectual history.

Golden Days
A Story

Eliot L. Wagner

A Story.

Dashiell Hammett's “Private Eye”:
No Loyalty Beyond the Job

David T. Bazelon

The figure of the rough and tough private detective—or the “private eye,” as we have come to call him with our circulating library knowingness—is one of the key creations of American popular culture.

From the American Scene: Fifty Years in the Canadian North

Raymond Rosenthal

An old man, Abe Weisman wasn't interested in pleasing any more, so he told his stories for their own sake, for himself more than for you.

Cedars of Lebanon: Prophets and Prophecy

Judaism's emphasis on the human nature and human qualities of the prophets was directed against the Christian-pagan notion of a man-God.

On the Horizon: Culture Conference at the Waldorf

William Barrett

“Was the Conference really Communist-dominated?” a woman of my acquaintance asked.

The Study of Man: Good Stocks and Lesser Breeds

Edward N. Saveth

It is scarcely in the nature of an exposé to point out that American legislation on immigration in the past quarter-century, up to and including the recent displaced-persons act, has pandered to the myth of “Nordic superiority.”

Shalom Means Peace, by Robert St. John

Reviewed by Nathan Glazer

Ferdinand Lassalle, by David Footman

Reviewed by Samuel J. Hurwitz

 June, 1949

The Economic Test Facing Israel:
A First-Hand Report

Hal Lehrman

A short time ago an ex-minister in the Churchill wartime government divulged to a high official in the Ben Gurion wartime government his deep anxiety over the economic problems confronting the infant State of Israel.

Young America Takes Over the Colleges:
The Two Worlds of the School

Arnold W. Green

The commemorative postage stamp issued in honor of Youth Month (September 1948) depicts a welldressed boy and girl, striding forward, with school books clutched under their arms.

The New Anti-Semitism of the Soviet Union:
Its Background and Its Meaning

Solomon M. Schwarz

Even among the severest critics of the Soviet Union, it was until recently acknowledged that the “new” Russia had wiped out anti-Semitism.

Portrait of the Mythical Gentile:
One Stereotype Breeds Another

Wayne Clark

During the past five years we have seen the most rapid construction of a literary myth since the carpentry of the Byronic hero.

Teach Us to Mark This, God

Franz Werfel

A Poem.

The French Intellectual Merry-Go-Round:
Right, Left, Up and Down

Sherry Mangan

The postwar resumption of transatlantic cultural communications brought American Francophiles a series of surprises.

The Re-Creation of Hebrew:
A “Dead Language” Lives Again

Ralph Weiman

In a sense the most amazing feat of Zionism has been the revival of Hebrew.

The Happy One
A Story

Edgar Rosenberg

A Story.

No More than Human:
Four Reflections on Judaism

Jacob Sloan

I am writing this the evening after the Day of Atonement, and I hope that I shall not be thought facetious when I say that Professor Heschel's words leave me with a sense of combined guilt and indifference.

From the American Scene: West Bronx: Food, Shelter, Clothing

Ruth Glazer

When the Woodlawn Road-Jerome Avenue express rushes out of the tunnel at 161st Street in the Bronx, the subway rider catches a glimpse of rows of six-story apartment houses flanking the elevated tracks on both sides and extending far back into the hinterland.

Cedars of Lebanon: The Nag

This is Mendele the Book-Peddler speaking.

On the Horizon: The Opportunity of the Jewish Museum

Heinz Politzer

The permanent collection of the Jewish Museum consists largely of liturgical objects, from arks of the Torah to spice-boxes.

The Study of Man: Prophets, Priests, and Social Scientists

Albert Salomon

So great is modern man's faith in the potentialities of science that he takes it for granted that the science of sociology must have much of importance to say concerning religion.

The Myth of the Jew

Reader Letters

Psychoanalysis and Ethics

Reader Letters

Marx's Legacy

Reader Letters

Change and Fossilization

Reader Letters

Christians and Jews

Reader Letters

“Doctor Faustus”

Reader Letters

Three Books by Morris R. Cohen

Reviewed by Israel Knox

Guard of Honor, by James Gould Cozzens

Reviewed by George Becker

 July, 1949

The Communist:
His Mentality and His Morals

Harold Rosenberg

The Englishman of Gilbert and Sullivan's era may have been born either a Liberal or a Conservative, but no one was ever born a Communist.

The Israelis Learn to Govern Themselves:
Politics and Politicians in the New State

Hal Lehrman

In a moving-picture theater called Kessem (“Magic”), the Parliament of Israel is in session.

The Intellectuals and the Jewish Community:
The Hope for Our Heritage in America

Elliot E. Cohen

The word “culture” is again being heard in the American Jewish community—after a decade's absence.

Uncle Remus and the Malevolent Rabbit:
Takes a Limber-Toe Gemmun fer ter Jump Jim Crow

Bernard Wolfe

Aunt Jemima, Beulah, the Gold Dust Twins, “George” the Pullmanad porter Uncle Remus . . . . We like to picture the Negro as grinning at us.

Mermaid
A Story

Nathan Halper

A Story.

Commencement

Milton Kaplan

A Poem.

The Myth of the Parasitic Middleman:
“Productive” and “Unproductive” Labor

Abba P. Lerner

Parasite, leech, vampire, symbol of unproductiveness and irresponsibility—these are familiar terms for that classic modern villain: the middleman.

The Vindictive and the Merciful:
God of Wrath and God of Love

Milton Himmelfarb

I used to think I was fooling my father, but now I suspect that he knew all along and did not want to make an issue of it.

The Irrepressible Herr Schacht:
Hitler's Adviser Stages a Comeback

Alfred Werner

When Wilhelm Schacht, German newspaperman, gave his newly born son Hjalmar the middle names “Horace Greeley,” it is possible that he was aware of the noble statement once made by the founder of the New York Tribune.

From the American Scene: Revolt of the Reefer-Makers

S. L. Blumenson

One sunny spring day in the year 1905, a cloak operator named Friedland (prophetically nicknamed “Columbus” by his fellow workers) pulled a switch that set in motion a train of events which was to wipe out the sweat shop and begin a new era in the garment industry.

Cedars of Lebanon: Men and Women

Reader Letters

Proverbs from the Aggadah.

On the Horizon: Israeli Music in America

Peter Gradenwitz

It was on my first morning in New York City last summer that I came upon Israeli music “Made in the USA.”

The Study of Man:The Idea of “Race” Dies Hard:

Melvin J. Tumin

The belief that the behavior of individuals is a biological legacy passed on from one generation to the next runs tenaciously through all our history.

The Hebrew Alphabet

Reader Letters

A Bronxite Protests

Reader Letters

Commentary's Influence

Reader Letters

Go Fight City Hall, by Ethel Rosenberg

Reviewed by Paul Goodman

The American Political Tradition, by Richard Hofstadter

Reviewed by Oscar Handlin

FOR the last quarter-century and more, a dull dead hand has rested over the writing of American political history. This aspect of the past is universally accounted important: every schoolboy...

 August, 1949

On the Agenda: Death:
A Document of the Jewish Resistance

Reader Letters

The document here printed has a special place in the treasury of literature devoted to Jewish resistance to the Nazis.

Religion By Fiat in Israel:
Ben Gurion Tacks Around the Church-State Issue

Hal Lehrman

As a veteran of Passover Week in Tel Aviv, this writer can testify at first hand to the intervention of religious rites and practices in the private lives of all persons, pious or infidel, Jew or Gentile, inhabiting the infant State of Israel.

The Knickerbocker Case:
A Report on the Current Crusade

Morris Freedman

There is being acted out in New York, in a kind of slow motion, with great gaps between the significant scenes, a public drama with a cast which occasionally reaches into the thousands.

The Key to Kafka:
What is His True Significance?

Hermann Goldschmidt

The name of Franz Kafka, scarcely known twenty-five years ago when he died with his most important works still unpublished, today echoes round the world.

The Schooling of David Dubinsky:
A Democratic Labor Leader in the Making

Waclaw Solski

David Dubinsky was born David Dobnievski in Brest-Litovsk fifty-seven years ago.

The Stranger and the Victim:
The Two Jewish Stereotypes of American Fiction

Irving Howe

Most novels about American Jews are afflicted with stereotyped characterizations.

Big Crash Out West

Peter Viereck

A Poem.

This Ancient Cloud
a Story

Michael Seide

A Story.

The Look

Babette Deutsch

A Poem.

Judeo-European Literary Miscellany:
A Report on Post-War Cultural Activity

David Scheinert

A Yiddish puppet show, “Hakl-Bakl,” is much talked about in Paris.

From the American Scene: Brownsville's Age of Learning

Samuel Tenenbaum

Brownsville, you should know, was originally settled by the overflow of people that spilled out of the tenements and slums of New York's East Side.

Cedars of Lebanon: Some Yiddish Proverbs

Reader Letters

A proverb is generally said to be a concentrate of folklore and folk-sagacity, a statement earthy, popular, and with an immediately felt point.

On the Horizon: Training Film for Democrats

Richard M. Clurman

Home of the Brave is the latest in what by now is a familiar American cultural product: the “problem movie.”

On the Horizon: Messiah of Lettrisme

Nicolas Clarion

There is not a single habitué of the Parisian literary cafés, and scarcely a single French intellectual, who is not now aware of the existence of Isidor Isou.

The Study of Man: How Many Jews in America?

Sophia M. Robison

Closer to the art of divination than to science is the study of the American Jewish population today.

Not Bronx, but America

Reader Letters

Sociologists and Religion

Reader Letters

No Whitewash Brush

Reader Letters

The Road Between, by James T. Farrell

Reviewed by Wallace Markfield

The Essence of Judaism, by Leo Baeck

Reviewed by David Baumgardt

Nausea, by Jean-Paul Sartre

Reviewed by Seymour Krim

Essays in Jewish Biography, by Alexander Marx

Reviewed by Milton Himmelfarb

 September, 1949

The Jewish Writer and the English Literary Tradition: A Symposium: Part I

William Phillips, Paul Goodman, Louis Kronenberger and David Daiches

COMMENTARY has asked a number of Jewish writers to take up this problem in the form of a symposium, reporting briefly on how they deal with it both personally and in their work.

A Plea for Religious Freedom in Israel:
The American Experience Can Serve as a Guide

Milton R. Konvitz

There are many who, in a flush of enthusiasm, and perhaps under the influence of the doctrine of the Chosen People, insist that in future years the State of Israel is destined to be the teacher and the rest of mankind its pupils.

Why Democracy Is Losing in Germany:
Behind the Recent Elections

A. R. L.

The German federal elections of August 14 marked the difficult birth, thirty years after the promulgation of the Weimar Constitution, of a new German republic in the greater part of a dismembered Germany.

What Kind of Liberal Are You?:
A Classification of the Species

Robert Bendiner

Out of some 140,000,000 people in the United States, at least 139,500,000 are liberals, to hear them tell it, liberal having become a rough synonym for virtuous, decent, humane, and kind to animals.

Monuments

Earl Hendler

A Poem.

The Curious History of the Six-Pointed Star:
How the “Magen David” Became the Jewish Symbol

Gershom Scholem

The six-pointed star known as the Magen David or Shield of David, which is now emblazoned on the flag of the State of Israel, is from every point of view a cause for astonishment.

The Dream Life of the New Woman:
As Mirrored in Current “Historical” Heroines

David T. Bazelon

The avowed purpose of our popular culture is to afford its avid consumers a quick momentary satisfaction of their fantasies

A Cup of Tea
A Story

Julius Horwitz

A Story.

The U.A.W. Fights Race Prejudice:
Case History on the Industrial Front

Irving Howe and B. J. Widick

In the1920's Detroit became the unchallenged motor capital and thereby one of the great industrial centers of the world.

From the American Scene: By the Waters of the Grand Concourse

Isa Kapp

A New Yorker without too strict a sense of order and tradition can find all sorts of amiable places to live in the reasonable confusion of Manhattan.

Cedars of Lebanon: The World to Come and the Love of God

These two chapters, translated from the Hebrew by Shlomo Katz, are from the concluding section of the first book of Maimonides' Mishneh Torah, written in 1180, ten years before his better known Guide to the Perplexed.

On the Horizon: London 1949: Worm's Eye View

Harold Orlansky

I give you a strictly worm's eye view of London, with no pretensions of raising my head an inch above the ground.

On the Horizon: The Art of Yankel Adler

Alfred Werner

The reception given by the New York critics to Yankel Adler's first show in America, at Knoedler's, in the fall of 1948, was rather cool, if not hostile.

A Song of Degrees

Howard Nemerov

A Poem.

The Study of Man: The New Anthropology and Its Ambitions

Robert Endleman

There is a New Look in anthropology, that omnibus “science of man.”

Views on Middlemen

Reader Letters

Hebrew A Barrier?

Reader Letters

Nineteen Eighty-Four, by George Orwell

Reviewed by Martin Greenberg

This Was America, ed. by Oscar Handlin

Reviewed by Robert Gorham Davis

Judaism: A Way of Life, by Samuel S. Cohon

Reviewed by Emil L. Fackenheim

Pilgrims in a New Land, by Lee M. Friedman

Reviewed by Marvin Meyers

 October, 1949

A Dialogue of Two Histories:
“Jewish Contributions to America” in a New Light

Daniel J. Boorstin

Apologists of Judaism in recent years, in a frenetic search for identities, have dulled their vision of what is distinctive in either the Jewish or the American experience.

Summoning God

Ralph Gordon

A Poem.

Gathering Storm in U.S.-Israeli Relations:
The Issues Behind the Conflict

Hal Lehrman

Inside Israel a visitor needs only to look around to persuade himself that it is academic to discuss taking back any large number of Arab refugees or giving away any substantial piece of Israeli-held territory.

Academic Integrity and Academic Freedom:
How to Deal with the Fellow-Travelling Professor

Sidney Hook

The current discussion of the question whether members of the Communist party should be permitted to teach in our schools and colleges has been conducted in such a way that it has eclipsed much more important problems concerning the character and direction of American education.

American Zionism at an Impasse:
A Movement in Search of a Program

Arthur Hertzberg

My Grandfather was not a Zionist, and yet my first experience of Zionism was an act of identification with him—and rebellion against my father.

From Little Nemo to Li'l Abner:
Comic Strips as Present-Day American Folklore

Heinz Politzer

On the heels of the Truman election came the publication of Al Capp's Life and Times of the Shmoo.

The Shooting on the Moehlstrasse:
Is It Nazi Anti-Semitism All Over Again?

Norbert Muhlen

In August the world press excitedly reported that the Moehlstrasse in Munich had been the scene of the “worst anti-Semitic outbursts since Hitler.”

The Jewish Writer and the English Literary Tradition: A Symposium-Part II

Philip Rahv, James Grossman, Martin Greenberg and Harry Levin

The editors of COMMENTARY asked twenty writers to discuss their reactions, as writers and readers, to the continuing presence of the sinister “Jew” in English literature.

How We Used to Laugh!
A Story

Ruth Glazer

A Story.

From the American Scene: The Service of the Temple

Grace Goldin

Reba Grossinger was one of the wealthiest women in Stillwater Falls.

Your Life

Moshe Leib Halpern

A Poem.

Cedars of Lebanon: The Holy

Franz Rosenzweig

Rosenzweig tells us what it is that one sees when one sees with faith—not so much what the faith is.

On the Horizon: Adam and Eve on Delancey Street

Isaac Rosenfeld

It is months now that a crowd, several rows deep, has been gathering at the window of an East Side delicatessen store to watch Kosher Fry Beef come off the slicing machine.

The Study of Man: Philosophy's Future in Our Scientific Age

John Dewey

Few persons today would deny that philosophy has greatly declined in esteem and influence since the time when it was held to be the Science of Sciences and the Art of Arts.

The Knickerbocker Case

Reader Letters

Mr. Freedman Replies

Reader Letters

Another View

Reader Letters

L'Chayim! ed. by Immanuel Olsvanger

Reviewed by Nathan Glick

Judaic Lore in Heine, by Israel Tabak

Reviewed by David Daiches

A Mencken Chrestomathy, by H. L. Mencken

Reviewed by Raymond Rosenthal

The World of Emma Lazarus, by H. E. Jacob

Reviewed by Marvin Meyers

 November, 1949

Group Life Within the American Pattern:
Its Scope and Its Limits

Oscar Handlin

“These people associate as easily as they breathe,” wrote Fredrika Bremer of the Americans in 1853.

Did F.D.R. Escape Wilson's Failure?
Idealism vs. Power Politics in American Foreign Policy

Richard H. S.

Great men are an encumbrance as well as an inspiration to the nations and the parties they lead.

Stuyvesant Town's Threat to Our Liberties:
Government Waives the Constitution for Private Enterprise

Charles Abrams

Last July, New York's highest court, by a four to three decision, upheld the J right of the Metropolitan Life Insurance Company to bar Negroes from its Stuyvesant Town housing project.

God and the Psychoanalysts:
Can Freud and Religion Be Reconciled?

Irving Kristol

Psychoanalysis was from its very beginnings disrespectful, when not positively hostile, towards all existing religious creeds and institutions.

An Evening with Israel's Poets:
Creative Voices in a Time of Trouble

Herbert Howarth

“These people can teach us how to live,” said Bill Williams to me in an aside after dinner.

The Conspirators
A Story

Julius Horwitz

A Story.

Hitler and the Gypsies:
The Fate of Europe's Oldest Aryans

Dora E. Yates

It is more than time that civilized men and women were aware of the Nazi crime against the Gypsies, as well as the Jews.

On the Margin in France:
Life in a World of Uneasy Moneys

Milton Klonsky

You don't have to be a millionaire to appreciate our own well-bred, balanced, clean-cut American dollar that, out of its heart of gold, endows and supports the world.

From the American Scene: The Kanliper B.&S.B.S of N.Y.

Harry Gersh

My Grandfather Berl, olav hasholem, worried a lot about the younger generation. H

Cedars of Lebanon: Portrait of a Hebraist

J. J. Trunk

Reb Benjamin was the “idler,” if one may use the term, in this energetic household.

On the Horizon: The Folk Revival in Jewish Music

Kurt List

To the casual observer, the 1948-49 season of Jewish music seemed no doubt a remarkably prosperous one.

The Study of Man:“The American Soldier” as Science

Nathan Glazer

The ambition of American social science is to arrive at general laws of society and human behavior: laws that shall be as universal, as precise, and as useful as Newton's.

Dr. Konvitz Replies

Reader Letters

Further Comment

Reader Letters

On Jewish Fiction

Reader Letters

Academic Fellow-Travelers

Reader Letters

Mr. Rosenfeld's Article

Reader Letters

Promise and Fulfilment, by Arthur Koestler

Reviewed by George Lichtheim

Image and Idea, by Philip Rahv

Reviewed by Leslie A. Fiedler

America and Cosmic Man, by Wyndham Lewis

Reviewed by Dennis H. Wrong

 December, 1949

Social Security Under the Union Label?
Labor's Welfare Drive and the Fair Deal

A. H. Raskin

One of the most reassuring aspects of our democracy is the frequency with which constructive results emerge from the most extraordinarily muddled situations.

The Arabs of Israel:
Pages from a Correspondent's Notebook

Hal Lehrman

Ramleh (March 1949)—“Only six months,” a Rumanian at the Bir Yaakov immigrant reception center sighed.

The Artist as Witness of Freedom:
The Independent Mind in an Age of Ideologies

Albert Camus

We are living in a time when men, impelled by mediocre and ferocious ideologies, have got into the habit of being ashamed of everything—ashamed of themselves, of being happy, of loving or creating.

The Rabbi

Ralph Gordon

A Poem.

Slow Revolution in Richmond, Va.:
A New Pattern in the Making

David and Adele Bernstein

Social change is seeping through Richmond, Virginia, as quietly and pervasively as the aroma of tobacco from the mills down near the James River.

Books for Jewish Children:
The Limits of the Didactic Approach

Isa Kapp

There was once a time when very few children's books were published and children roamed like explorers through adult libraries, investing Dickens and Defoe with all the credulity and awe of their own fantasy world.

The Jews of Kurdistan:
A First-Hand Report on a Near Eastern Mountain Community

Walter J. Fischel

When I set out to visit Kurdistan I was aware that Jewish communities existed in such towns as Kirkuk, Arbil, and Mosul.

Kafka: Ritual Without Religion:
The Modern Intellectual's Shamefaced Atheism

Guenther Anders

Almost insensibly the figure of Franz Kafka has usurped a dominant position in modem literature.

Small Perfect Manhattan

Peter Viereck

A Poem.

From the American Scene: Report from the Farm

Earl Raab

We are in the “cow business”—permanently, we think—but the Fable of the Chicken and the not down.

Cedars of Lebanon: The Death of Tammuz

Saul Tschernichowsky

A Poem.

On the Horizon: Sholom Aleichem in Exile

Israel Cohen

Rummaging recently among an accumulation of old letters and papers, I came across some letters in Yiddish, written in a small, neat hand, and signed with an elaborate and indecipherable flourish, which immediately evoked a train of pleasant memories.

The Study of Man: A Broader Approach to Jewish History

H. Schmidt

A glance at Jewish Jerusalem today reveals an astonishing variety of social groups that seem to live their lives in more or less separate compartments.

Mr. Rosenfeld's Article

Reader Letters

Professor Hook Replies

Reader Letters

On “Commentary”

Reader Letters

The Stuyvesant Town Case

Reader Letters

Strategy for Liberals, by Irwin Ross

Reviewed by Daniel Bell

Advertisement

image of latest cover
image of latest cover

ADVERTISER LINKS

Advertisement