xTooltipElement
    1. Obama's Enemies List
      Peter Wehner
    2. Islamist Extremism and the Murder of Daniel Pearl
      Joseph I. Lieberman
    3. Why Obama Is Wrong on Missile Defense
      Steven Price
    4. How Politics Destroyed a Great TV Show
      Jonah Goldberg
      October 2009
    5. Why Are Jews Liberals?—A Symposium
      David Wolpe, Jonathan D. Sarna, Michael Medved, William Kristol and Jeff Jacoby
      September 2009

Advertisement



1961
View: All Months | Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec

 January, 1961

Harry Golden & the American Audience

Theodore Solotaroff

In early October, 1958, the ladies of the Delphian Club of Forrest City, Arkansas, met for one of their literary afternoons. The "theme" of the program was "Americanism," which the club members illustrated by the book that had been chosen for discussion--Harry Golden's "Only in America."

Political Crisis in France

Ray Alan

In between convulsions, France is one of the most conservative countries in Europe.

Moral Crisis in France

Joseph Barry

France, said Gertrude Stein, always rises from the ashes. And now France is rising from the dirty ashes of the Algerian war, oddly regenerated by the smoldering heat of that disaster.

The Jewish Intellectual in Israel

Mati Meged

During a short stay in New York last year, I was invited by a group of Jewish students at Columbia University to speak to them about literary life in Israel. Looking at their tense young faces, I was reminded of how I too used to feel the same ardent yearning at any lecture I attended, and I was powerfully struck by the realization that this yearning scarcely exists among young Israelis.

Urban Renewal-For Whom?

Staughton Lynd

The persistence of America's slum problem has been discussed in this magazine by Michael Harrington. Here it is my purpose to explore the ideological basis for this failure.

Christianity in a “Post-Western” Era

David Danzig

Perhaps the major recent development within Christianity has been the growing awareness of both Catholics and Protestants that Christianity's aspiration toward universality has been gravely compromised by its identification with the history and culture of the West.

The Man on His Back
A Story

Karl Fruchtmann

A story.

The Study of Man: Voting Practices versus Democratic Theory

R. A. Nisbet

The relation of man to state is a timeless problem, one that provides a sturdy bridge from Plato to the Michigan Survey on elections.

“The Wall” on Broadway

George Ross

"The Wall," both the novel and the play, is the story of the Warsaw uprising in 1943 against the Nazis. It is a celebration of the outstanding instance of Jewish resistance to the Germans.

Affluence

Ernest van den, Lewis A. Coser and Ben B. Seligman

Lewis A. Coser--an associate professor of sociology at Brandeis--and Ben B. Seligman--a labor economist--here comment on "Affluence, Galbraith, the Democrats," an article by Ernest Van Den Haag, which appeared in our September issue. An answer by Mr. van den Haag follows.

Scholarship & Rebellion

Reader Letters

“Pharisaical”

Reader Letters

Soviet Anti-Semitism

Reader Letters

A Liberal's Judaism

Reader Letters

Discrepancy

Reader Letters

The Waste Makers, by Vance Packard

Reviewed by Seymour Martin Lipset

Vance Packard has achieved notable financial and critical success with his two previous books, "The Hidden Persuaders" and "The Status Seekers," both of them harsh attacks on the mores of the business society. "The Waste Makers" now adds a third piece to what Mr. Packard's publishers describe as a continuing study of American society.

Andrew Johnson & Reconstruction, by Eric L. McKitrick

Reviewed by John Braeman

Its blind spots notwithstanding, "Andrew Johnson and Reconstruction" heralds the appearance of a major new historian.

Law & Tradition in Judaism, by Boaz Cohen

Reviewed by Sefton D. Temkin

A recent collection of papers descriptive of Conservative Judaism bears the title "Tradition and Change." And a survey of the forces at work within Conservative Judaism would suggest that its major organ, the Jewish Theological Seminary, stands as the guardian of tradition.

Frontiers in American Democracy, by Eugene J. McCarthy; The Conscience of a Conservative,by Barry Goldwater; U.S. Senators and their World, by Donald R. Matthews

Reviewed by Andrew Hacker

More than the presidency, the Supreme Court, or even the House of Representatives, the Senate remains the home of extreme positions and principled appeals

Some Recent Jewish Books

Reviewed by Milton Himmelfarb

In the past year or two paperback reprints of many first-rate books have been published. I shall list here some of Schocken Books' paperbacks, and those of other publishers.

 February, 1961

Israel & the A-Bomb

Gidon Gottlieb

Is Israel capable, or desirous, of manufacturing atom bombs? If so, what should be done about it?

The Lavon Affair

S. Z. Abramov

At this writing, the final outcome of the Lavon affair--which three months ago triggered the most serious political crisis in the history of Israel--is still uncertain.

Prospect for a New Foreign Policy

Hans J. Morgenthau

Exactly eight years ago, I sat down to write an article explaining why great things could be expected from Messrs. Eisenhower and Dulles in the conduct of American foreign policy. Yet before I was able to finish, certain depressing indications of what the new foreign policy was likely to be, had already appeared. These sobering reminiscences provide an appropriate background for evaluating the prospects of American foreign policy under the new administration.

“Empiricism” and British Politics

Norman Birnbaum

Ideology and actuality are everywhere in conflict, but nowhere in Western Europe is that conflict so strenuously denied as in Britain.

Danilo Dolci: Non-Violence in Italy

Kathleen Nott

When I arrived in Sicily last spring, my hostess told me, with some excitement, that Danilo Dolci was holding an international conference on theme of the backward areas of Sicily. Dolci is the young artist-architect, now thirty-six, turned saintly reformer, the exponent of the philosophy of non-violence, who has dedicated himself to the purpose of reclaiming Sicily and the Sicilians.

Jewish Writers In America:
A Place in the Establishment

Benjamin De Mott

Since the hesitations or reservations or embarrassments of the Jewish critic have greater than local effect now, and may increase in influence, an imprecise account of their bearings is probably a shade better than none at all.

Jewish Writers In England:
A Tradition Begins

Henry Popkin

During the past few years several new Jewish novelists and playwrights have attracted considerable attention in the British literary world.

The Origin of the Cold War: An Exchange

Moshe Decter, Wm. Appleman Williams, George Lichtheim and Staughton Lynd

In his article, "How the Cold War Began" (November 1960), Staughton Lynd attempted to view the struggle between the West and the Communist bloc "with the kind of perspective which commonly comes only after the passage of much time." The exchange between Mr. Lynd and three of his critics is published below.

The Study of Man: Sizing Up the Mass Media

Harris Dienstfrey

One way of approaching an evaluation of the mass media is to ask whether it sees the media as an old or a new thing.

Resistance, Rebellion & Death, by Albert Camus

Reviewed by Lionel Abel

In "Resistance, Rebellion and Death," we see Albert Camus at his most spontaneous, responding to problems as they arose and to events as they occurred.

Working-Class Suburb, by Bennet M. Berger

Reviewed by Ronald Gross

Suburbia is a place, not a way of life. But where does this conclusion leave the image of suburban living on which such a booming business in social commentary has subsisted for the past five years?

Jewish Gnosticism, Merkabah Mysticism, and Talmudic Tradition, by Gershom G. Scholem

Reviewed by Jakob J. Petuchowski

Professor Scholem's latest work is a scholar's book--in both sense of that phrase.

The Beat of Life, by Barbara Probst Solomon

Reviewed by Jane Hayman

If we are to believe the recent talk, a revolution is taking place on our campuses that makes the young people in Barbara Probst Solomon's novel, "The Beat of Life," look definitely old-hat.

America in the Sixties, by the Editors of Fortune; Beyond the Welfare State, by Gunnar Myrdal; The Powerful Consumer, by George Katona

Reviewed by Lewis A. Coser

These three books are all concerned with topics that border on the area between sociology and economics. But they are otherwise most dissimilar.

 March, 1961

The Strategy of Deterrence:
A Dissenting Statement

H. Stuart Hughes

"Deterrence," Kissinger tells us, "requires a combination of power, the will to use it, and the assessment of these by the potential aggressor." Kahn or Schelling or Murray could have written the same.

Ben Gurion Against the Diaspora:
Three Comments

Oscar Handlin, Milton Himmelfarb and Charles E. Shulman

In an address before the World Zionist Congress, which met last December in Jerusalem, David Ben Gurion reiterated his belief that Jewish life in the Diaspora has a dim future. "Commentary" invited three prominent American-Jewish intellectuals to explore some of the wider implications of Ben Gurion's speech.

Pornography, Art, and Censorship

Paul Goodman

Present thinking about obscenity and pornography is wrongheaded and damaging.

Shiddah and Kuziba
A Story

Isaac Bashevis Singer

A story.

The New Administration & Organized Labor

Tom Brooks

The air of expectancy that has surrounded the beginnings of the Kennedy administration has a decided piquancy for organized labor.

Writing American Fiction

Philip Roth

The American writer in the middle of the 20th century has his hands full in trying to understand, and then describe, and then make credible much of the American reality.

The Dead Hasidim: Part I

Herbert Weiner

In the small Jerusalem quarter of Mea Shearim--which houses the most intense concentration of Jewish Orthodoxy in the world--an unusual literary circle meets daily.

Women at Work

Midge Decter

What the current statistics on the whole question of womanpower reveal about the crisis in the inner life of the American woman is not so certain as some psychiatrists and social workers would have us believe.

By the Light of the Silvery Screen

Wallace Markfield

The intellectual who turns film critic is letting himself in for a rough time.

Problems of Urban Renewal

Reader Letters

Middle-Class Rebellion

Reader Letters

Drug Addiction, Continued

Reader Letters

“Cannibals All!”

Reader Letters

Progress, More Progress

Reader Letters

Thought and Action, by Stuart Hampshire

Reviewed by Richard J. Bernstein

Stuart Hampshire is a philosopher who has written urbanely and incisively on literary, political, and philosophic subjects. "Thought and Action," Hampshire's first sustained attempt to survey a complex web of philosophic issues, is, nevertheless, extremely disappointing.

The Faithful City, by Dov Joseph; A Clash of Destinies, by Jon and David Kimche

Reviewed by R. H. S.

"The Faithful City" has all the vitality of a personal document. The picture it gives is all the more vivid because it is written in an unadorned, vigorous English.

The Go-Away Bird and Other Stories, by Muriel Spark

Reviewed by Thomas Rogers

Muriel Spark is an English writer of great originality, who, since 1957, has published five novels and this collection of eleven short stories.

Graduate Education in the United States, by Bernard Berelson

Reviewed by Lewis A. Coser

This volume provides--as they say--a gold mine of information about the state of graduate studies in America.

Year Book of the Leo Baeck Institute (Volumes I-IV), edited by Robert Weltsch; Aufbau Im Untergang, by Ernst Simon; Ostjuden in Deutschland, 1880-1940, by S. Adler-Rudel

Reviewed by Ernest Stock

The publications of the Leo Baeck Institute, of which some sixteen have now appeared, have the common purpose of exploring the "spiritual features of German Jewry"--its "inner development in the fields of philosophy, religion, science, economics and art...the external events which affected that development.

 April, 1961

Political Economy & the New Administration

Oscar Gass

In the first phase of his White House career, President Kennedy has thrilled his American audiences with the call to sacrifice and comforted them by not asking for any.

The Peace Movement in America ... 1961

Nathan Glazer

Why is it that the peace movement in America has never been able to attract the kind of mass support which has gathered around the peace movement in England?

Challenge to Negro Leadership

Julian Mayfield

For some time now it has been apparent that the traditional leadership of the American Negro community--a leadership which has been largely middle class in origin and orientation--is in danger of losing its claim to speak for the masses of Negroes.

Jewishness & the Younger Intellectuals: Introduction

Norman Podhoretz

In February 1944-some two years after America's entry into World War II and less than two years before the end of the war-"Commentary's" forerunner, the "Contemporary Jewish Record," published a symposium on American literature and the younger generation of American Jews. While all this was taking place in the generation that is now between forty-five and fifty-five years old, a new generation of American Jews was beginning to make its appearance on the scene.

Jewishness & the Younger Intellectuals: Contributors

Raziel Abelson, Alfred G. Aronowitz and Aaron Asher

"Commentary" asked a group of thirty-one intellectuals: Do you feel that the situation of the Jew in America has altered in the past fifteen years? Do you think your experience as a Jew is importantly relevant to your experience as an American? Have you ever considered the possibility that your children may convert to another religion?

The Novels of Vance Bourjaily

Harris Dienstfrey

The four novels of Vance Bourjaily have not received much attention, partly, I think, because they have not been properly understood.

Analyzing “The Wall”

Reader Letters

Lavon and the Military

Reader Letters

Revolutionary Democracy

Reader Letters

 May, 1961

The Future of NATO

Denis Healey

The establishment of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization in 1949 was the culmination of the most creative period in recent diplomatic history. If one thing is certain it is that NATO cannot now turn the clock back ten years and start again.

The Sino-Soviet Dispute

Richard Lowenthal

The policy declaration and the appeal to the peoples of the world adopted last December by the Moscow conference of eighty-one Communist parties mark the end of one phase in the dispute between the leaderships of the ruling parties of China and the Soviet Union.

The Chronicles of Dos Passos

Richard Chase

The longer John Dos passos writes, the more one admires his integrity, his hard-won skill, his capacity for work, and whether one agrees with him or not, the forthrightness of his political views.

Apologia for a Confirmation Text

Emil L. Fackenheim

It is unusual nowadays for serious thinkers of any kind to address themselves directly to an audience of children, but it is perhaps even more surprising to find a Sunday school text being written by a leading Jewish religious thinker. "Commentary" asked Emil Fackenheim if he would discuss in an article why he undertook to write such a book and what kinds of problems he encountered.

Lincoln Center: Planning for Music

Joan Peyser

After a year-long "public participation program," last September, a professional survey sponsored by the Lincoln Center for the Performing Arts revealed the following bit of information: "As many people know about Lincoln Center as know about the Great Pyramids." Left unanswered, however, was the question: What is it that people know about Lincoln Center.

The Dead Hasidim: Part II

Herbert Weiner

For the followers of Rabbi Nachman of Bratzlav, a famous Hasidic master (1772-1811), the hearing and telling of their founder's stories is a mode of worship.

Electioneering Among the Minorities

Roma Lipsky

The existence of a minority group vote in America, or indeed of any bloc voting groups, is proclaimed and denied with about equal vigor--often by the same people.

Arthur Miller Out West

Henry Popkin

Arthur Miller's movie, "The Misfits," is a curious article. It continues several of Miller's favorite preoccupations and, in some respects, it is a sequel to "Death of a Salesman"; but it is a violently forced dramatization of a theme.

The Rational Symposiasts & Other Matters

Milton Himmelfarb

Many states require adoptive parents to be of the same religion as the natural mother, so far as possible. In hearings in February, before the law was enacted, everyone agreed that better control of private adoptions was necessary, but there was disagreement about matching.

The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich by William L. Shirer

Reviewed by George Lichtheim

Hitler's Reich continues to fascinate the historians, more especially perhaps the amateur historians. In fact, of course, Mr. Shirer has written nothing like the definitive historical study of the third Reich which it has been his ambition to compose for the benefit of future generations.

The Nephew, by James Purdy; Ceremony in Lone Tree, by Wright Morris

Reviewed by Elizabeth Tornquist

Ralph Ellison has written that the novel communicates a moral vision "by amplifying and giving resonance to a specific complex of experience until, through the eloquence of its statement, that specific part of life speaks metaphorically for the whole."

The Leopard's Spots, by William Stanton; Louis Agassiz, by Edward Lurie

Reviewed by Christopher Jencks

For those who like to think of science as an orderly and progressive march toward ultimate truth, neither William Stanton nor Edward Lurie is likely to provide very agreeable reading.

Peaceable Lane, by Keith Wheeler; First Family, by Christopher Davis

Reviewed by Milton Hindus

Both Mr. Wheeler's story and Mr. Davis's are extremely pathetic, and optimistic readers are sure to be frustrated, provoked, and even alarmed by their portrayals of futility.

The Servants of Power, by Loren Baritz

Reviewed by Walter Karp

It is one sign of the times that a swarm of psychologists, sociologists, psychiatrists, human relations experts, and similar quasiacademics now occupy high staff positions in most of America's large industrial corporations. How all these thinkers got into the land of the hardheaded businessman is a revealing bit of 20th-century history that Loren Baritz somewhat portentously examines in his new book, "The Servants of Power."

Der Judische Witz, by Salcia Landmann

Reviewed by Isaac Bashevis Singer

Included in this book is a collection of over a thousand Jewish jokes, a brief but scholarly preface by Professor Carlo Schmid, and an introduction of some ninety pages in which the author--a doctor of philosophy--summarizes several general theories of humor and proposes a special "sociology" of the Jewish joke.

 June, 1961

“Bosses” and “Reformers”:
A Profile of the New York Democrats

Daniel P. Moynihan

Of all the institutions that Jefferson helped to found, there is surely none that would please him more, in its freedom from the burdens of tradition, than the New York Democrats.

Reflections on Jewish Identity

Daniel Bell

A persistent worried Jews of the early Diasporas and of Hellenistic times: the fear that a child of theirs might grow up to be an am-haaretz--a peasant, ignorant of Torah; or, even worse, an apikoros--a sophisticated unbeliever. A similar crisis of identity is a hallmark of our own modernity.

Betancourt's Venezuela:
Alternative to Castroism?

Samuel Shapiro

A crucial test of our policies in this hemisphere will come in Venezuela, Cuba's Caribbean neighbor, the richest nation in Latin America, governed by an exemplary liberal leader, but still plagued with economic and social problems.

Four Letters from the Warsaw Ghetto

Reader Letters

Halina Szwambaum died in the Warsaw Ghetto in April 1943, fighting alongside her lover in the final unsuccessful uprising of the seventy thousand. Halina managed to keep in constant touch with her woman friend. What follows is a translation of Halina's letters.

National Purpose & New Frontiers

Philip Green

The symposium on "National Purpose," the "Report of the President's Commission on National Goals," and the campaign addresses of John F. Kennedy, were all products of the same debate; they all, furthermore, were characterized by one quality in particular--the emphasis on "National Purpose" as a perspective from which American society could most usefully viewed.

The Mind of Robert Warshow

Lionel Trilling

Robert Warshow died in the spring of 1955. He was thirty-seven years old. In the circle of his friends the shock of his death was extreme--I have never known a death so intensely and openly grieved over.

Past Due
A Story

Meyer Liben

A story.

The Study of Man: Marxism & the Colonial Revolt

Paul Kecskemeti

The Western world is facing two great revolutionary currents--the Marxist onslaught, represented chiefly by Soviet and Chinese Communism, and the colonial revolt, aimed at throwing off Western control. How can we assess the significance of these revolutionary currents?

A Memoir of Jabotinsky

Dan Jacobson

Reading the first volume of "Rebel and Statesman: The Jabotinsky Story" by Joseph Schechtman has reminded me that it is now almost twenty-five years since I met Vladimir Jabotinsky, when in 1938 he visited our home in Kimberley, during a South African tour.

Algerian Independence & the Jews

Samuel L. Blumenfeld, Ray Alan and Joseph Barry

The discussion we present this month grew out of the companion articles on "Algeria & the Fifth Republic" which appeared in our January issue: Ray Alan's "The Political Crisis" and Joseph Barry's "The Moral Crisis." Samuel L. Blumenfeld here comments on both articles; replies by Mr. Alan and Mr. Barry follow.

The Symposium—I

Reader Letters

“Fortune” and America

Reader Letters

The Cold War

Reader Letters

The “Meaning” of Work

Reader Letters

The Supreme Court Review 1960, edited by Philip B. Kurland; The American Supreme Court, by Robert G. McCloskey

Reviewed by C. Peter Magrath

Modern Americans, enlightened by the writings of legal realists such as Justice Holmes and Jerome Frank, not to mention the Court fight of the 30's, know that within the robed judge dwells the man.

Scenes From Life, by William Cooper; Take a Girl Like You, by Kingsley Amis

Reviewed by Ellen Moers

Warmly reviewed for the American press by no less a literary couple than C. P. Snow and Pamela Hansford Johnson, William Cooper's "Scenes from Life" comes to us as the fountainhead of the English angry-young-man school

Jewish Existence, by Ignaz Maybaum

Reviewed by Walter H. Plaut

What we require is an exposition of the Jewish raison d'etre outside of Zion. Ignaz Maybaum's new book attempts to meet this need.

Political Man, by Seymour Martin Lipset

Reviewed by Andrew Hacker

Collections of essays that were previously published in various magazines usually make unsatisfactory books. Newly-written opening and closing chapters seek to develop a common theme, but the topics discussed are generally too diverse and the transitions too forced to impose a persuasive continuity.

The Wedding Band, by Samuel Yellen; The Acrophile, by Yoram Kaniuk

Reviewed by Jane Hayman

Samuel Yellen's "The Wedding Band" tells of an unhappy marriage. It is the sort of middle-class writing that tries to make barrenness palatable.

 July, 1961

Federal Aid to Parochial Schools:
A Debate

Ernest van den and Oscar Handlin

The issue of federal aid to parochial schools is often approached largely in terms of whether such aid is compatible with the separation between church and state. Yet many other questions of social policy are involved here as well. We have therefore invited two writers who take radically opposing views of how federal aid to private schools would affect it, to argue their cases for readers of "Commentary."

Israel During the Trial - A Journal

Hugh H. Nissenson

A journal of Hugh Nissenson's stay in Israel during the trial of Adolf Eichmann.

Utopian Thinking

Paul Goodman

After a long spell of Marxian "scientific" realism and businessmen's "hard-headed" realism, our social scientists have begun to praise "utopian thinking."

Varieties of African Nationalism

Walter Schwarz

Pan-Africanism is but one aspect of the nationalism now paramount in the newly independent states of Black Africa.

Crisis Theology & the Jewish Community

Eugene Borowitz

Jewish theology to be meaningful in the postwar world would have to speak to this problem--to man's talent for creating evil, to his capacity for deluding himself about the strength and subtlety of his evil inclination.

Asia: The American Algeria

Hans J. Morgenthau

This issue we inaugurate a bi-monthly department, "Public Affairs," in which Hans J. Morgenthau, one of America's most eminent political thinkers, will discuss leading questions of present concern. Here he likens France's problem with Algeria to America's problem with Asia.

The Study of Man: The American Scholar Today

Leo Marx

Some scholars may have been aware of it for a few years, but most of us have only begun to recognize that we are entering a new phase in the study of the American past.

Jane Addams & the Radical Impulse

Staughton Lynd

The impulse to radicalism has been getting a bad press. One hesitates, of course, to call Jane Addams a "radical."

Fashions in Vulgarity

Louis Kronenberger

Nothing, in a sense, seems easier to chronicle--perhaps in pictures alone--than a history of bad taste.

Deterrence

Irving Kristol and H. Stuart Hughes

The following discussion between Irving Kristol and H. Stuart Hughes grew out of Mr. Hughes's article in our March issue, "The Strategy of Deterrence-A Dissenting Statement."

The Symposium—II

Reader Letters

“Arms Control”

Reader Letters

Dealing with Pornography

Reader Letters

Jewish Writing in England

Reader Letters

A Correction

Reader Letters

The Schools, by Martin Mayer

Reviewed by Edgar Z. Friedenberg

Martin Mayer's "The Schools" is the best book about education I have ever read.

Israel: A Blessing and a Curse, by Hedley V. Cooke

Reviewed by Lucy S. Dawidowicz

Just as Israel often feels it must justify its existence in the international community, so some of its supporters still examine their consciences to reassure themselves about Israel's title to sovereignty.

A Mirror for Anglo-Saxons, by Martin Green

Reviewed by John Gross

Stifled in England, Mr. Green breathes freely in America.

Five Publications of the Commission on Race and Housing

Reviewed by Arnold M. Rose

These five books comprise a most remarkable contribution to applied social science.

Revolutionary Road, by Richard Yates

Reviewed by Theodore Solotaroff

I have a number of quarrels with "Revolutionary Road," but have only admiration for the way its author has turned flat, worked-over material into an arrestingly relevant novel.

 August, 1961

The John Birch Society

Alan F. Westin

The John Birch Society has become the most appealing, activist, and efficient movement to appear on the extreme right since the fertile decade of the 1930's.

The Genius of S. Y. Agnon

Robert Alter

S.Y. Agnon has devoted his life to creative writing--and with a permanent annual stipend from his publishers, he is probably the only Hebrew writer ever to make a comfortable living from his writing alone.

Forevermore

S. Y. Agnon

A story.

Their Canada and Mine

Mordecai Richler

A memoir.

Why Students Leave Science

Edgar Z. Friedenberg

Why do many American students drop the scientific careers which they have spent several years training for with reasonable success?

Pornography & Censorship

Richard Lichtman and Paul Goodman

The discussion we present this month grew out of Paul Goodman's article, "Pornography, Art & Censorship," which appeared in the March "Commentary." Richard Lichtman here takes issue with Mr. Goodman.

Plastic Men

Reader Letters

Intelligence and Peace

Reader Letters

Labor and the Public Good

Reader Letters

Survival in the Diaspora

Reader Letters

Criticizing Movies

Reader Letters

The Woman's Place

Reader Letters

The Futilitarian Society, by William J. Newman

Reviewed by Dennis H. Wrong

Although Professor Newman often tries to be funny at the expense of the assortment of publicists and thinkers he examines, he tells us repeatedly that they are not a joke, that they even constitute a menace for America.

Nachman Syrkin: Socialist Zionist, by Marie Syrkin

Reviewed by Milton Hindus

Nachman Syrkin was the founder of that political movement which has guided the State of Israel since its inception and which earned its leading place by the role it played in Palestinian life for many years before the state was founded.

As We Are, by Henry Brandon

Reviewed by Dan Jacobson

Rather to my surprise, I found "As We Are" a depressing book to go through. On the face of it, it shouldn't be depressing at all.

India & the West, by Barbara Ward

Reviewed by E. F. Schumacher

This engaging book, written by a highly accomplished writer, is a passionate appeal to the Western conscience to give economic aid to India on a much larger scale and firmer basis than has ever been contemplated hitherto.

Literature & the Press, by Louis Dudek

Reviewed by Harris Dienstfrey

"Literature and the Press," by Louis Dudek, mainly concerns itself with the development of print in England.

Some Recent Jewish Books

Reviewed by Milton Himmelfarb

Short reviews of "What it Means to be A Jew," by Charles E. Shulman, "On the Track of Tyranny," edited by Max Beloff, "No Easy Answers," by Philip M. Klutznick, and "The First Step: A Primer of a Jew's Spiritual Life," Selected by Meshullam Zalman et. al.

 September, 1961

Is New York City Ungovernable?

Nathan Glazer

A dangerous and sophisticated assumption to be avoided is that no solutions can be found to the problems of New York City.

Foreign Policy & the American Mind

Robert A. Nisbet

It is only too clear that behind the tactical and strategical problems of our relations with the rest of the world--not to emphasize the occasional humiliations--lie some major difficulties of perspective.

The “Normalization” of Israel

Mati Meged

During the past year, as the result of a number of crucial public controversies, Israelis have been forced to confront some of the basic contradictions underlying their political and social order.

Negro Militants, Jewish Liberals & the Unions

Tom Brooks

The fact is that the Negro-Jewish civil rights coalition now faces disruption, a dissolution that seems symptomatic of the worsening relations between white and Negro liberals in general.

English Poetry Today

A. Alvarez

In 1932 the critic F. R. Leavis proclaimed that T. S. Eliot and Ezra Pound had between them brought about a significant reorientation of literature. Twenty years later he took most of it back again.

The New Map of Christianity

David Danzig

For the first time in about four centuries, the wall between Catholics and Protestants, erected first on one side by the Reformation and then on the other by the counter-Reformation, has begun to be preached.

Death in the Nuclear Age

Hans J. Morgenthau

It is obvious that the nuclear age has radically changed man's relations to nature and to his fellow men.

Fertility, Social Action, Socialism

Milton Himmelfarb

In the latest volume of the "American Jewish Year Book" Erich Rosenthal shows that American Jews have stood aside from the baby boom.

Toynbee's Epistle to the Jews

Jacob B. Agus

Jacob B. Agus is rabbi of Beth El, a Conservative congregation in Baltimore. Ordained by the Rabbinical School of Yeshiva University, he also holds a doctorate from Harvard in the philosophy of religion. We invited him to comment on the significance of Toynbee's new analysis of Judaism.

The N.Y. Daily News

Murray Kempton

The "New York Daily News," shadow though it be, is for some of us the closest available instrument for an immediate reflection of the real life of our society. But to judge by John Chapman's recently published history the paper must have an uncommonly and unfairly low self-estimate.

Defense and Deterrence

Reader Letters

American Fiction

Reader Letters

Containment in Asia

Reader Letters

The Hasidim -- An Analogy

Reader Letters

Music at Linoln Center

Reader Letters

Curtains, by Kenneth Tynan

Reviewed by John Gross

Five hundred pages of collected Tynan, decked with a sumptuousness normally reserved for the Living Thoughts of major philosophers and the memoirs of field marshals: even the faithful must quail a little, confronted with the wisdom of the master in such bulk.

Great Western Mystics, by David Baumgardt; Nine Gates to the Chassidic Mysteries, by Jiri Langer

Reviewed by Isaac Bashevis Singer

"Great Western Mystics: Their Lasting Significance" contains three lectures presented by Professor David Baumgardt at Columbia University in November 1960. "Nine Gates to the Chassidic Mysteries presents a specific illustration of one of the schools of mysticism touched upon in Dr. Baumgardt's book.

The Transformation of Russian Society, edited by Cyril E. Black

Reviewed by Elisha Greifer

"The Transformation of Russian Society" cannot be praised too highly, for it gets on with the work.

Dawn, by Elie Wiesel

Reviewed by Irving Feldman

Though there is much that is excellent here--honest, sensitive, densely and finely wrought--"Dawn" is seldom moving.

Firsthand Report, by Sherman Adams

Reviewed by Joseph Kraft

From the far outside, American politics looks like a struggle between the two parties. From the middle distance, skirmishing between executive and legislature seems to predominate.

Ahad Ha-Am-Asher Ginzberg, by Leon Simon

Reviewed by Ezra Spicehandler

The problem Ahad Ha-Am posed, "the problem of Judaism" he called it, is still on the Jewish agenda. How can a Jew remain a Jew in an essentially secularized world?

Principles, Politics, and Fundamental Law, by Herbert Wechsler

Reviewed by C. Peter Magrath

This volume is to be commended for rescuing four important essays by one of the eminent figures in American constitutional law from the obscurity of the professional journals.

Contemporary Europe, by H. Stuart Hughes

Reviewed by George Lichtheim

It seems to have become the prerogative of American historians to see Europe as a whole.

 October, 1961

Western Values & Total War

Sidney Hook, H. Stuart Hughes, Hans J. Morgenthau and C. P. Snow

Last May, in observance of its fifteenth anniversary year, "Commentary" invited Sidney Hook, H. Stuart Hughes, Hans J. Morgenthau, and C. P. Snow to participate in a three-hour round-table discussion of the moral and political questions surrounding the possibility of a nuclear war. What follows is a slightly abridged transcript of the entire proceedings.

Martin Buber's Hasidism

Gershom Scholem

There can be no doubt that the contribution of Martin Buber to the Western world's knowledge of the Hasidic movement has been a most distinguished one.

“All that Cellar-Deep Jazz&rdquo

Theodore Solotaroff

The times seem to have caught up with Henry Miller, not only in the sexual sophistication that permits the recent publication of "Tropic of Cancer," but in the further respect of often seeming as disordered and self-destructive as he was claiming modern life to be in the early 1930's.

The British Way of Life-And the Common Market

George Lichtheim

Great events do not invariably occur to the accompaniment of thunderous displays of passion; not at any rate in Britain.

The Kibbutz in Crisis

Gerda Luft

Despite the fact that the Israeli kibbutz is in some ways an ideal place to live and work--that it offers absolute social security and even in many cases a relatively high standard of physical comfort--the collective settlements have for some years now been suffering from a shortage of manpower.

Jewish Identity

Reader Letters

Warshow and Trilling

Reader Letters

Our National Purpose

Reader Letters

Six American Poets

Reviewed by Harold Rosenberg

Ginsberg's "Kaddish" is a take-off on the Jewish prayer for the dead, not as it is printed in the prayer book but as it might occur in the mind of a contemporary mourner.

A Faith for Moderns, by Robert Gordis

Reviewed by Marvin Fox

One of the merits of the existentialist emphasis in current theological discussions is its avoidance of apologetics.

The Political Kingdom in Uganda, by David E. Apter

Reviewed by Walter Schwarz

Decolonization in Africa proceeds no less importantly in the fields of scholarship and culture than in politics, but the process is slower.

Mila 18, by Leon Uris

Reviewed by Midge Decter

The career of Mr. Leon Uris tells a curious literary and cultural story. It might at first not seem worthy of note that a gifted writer of hard-core trash should three times out of the last four have made the best-seller lists in America.

The Burden of Southern History, by C. Vann Woodward; The Confederacy, by Charles P. Roland

Reviewed by Samuel Shapiro

C. Vann Woodward is a distinguished member of that group of Southern scholars who have in recent years attempted to destroy persistent and pernicious myths about their section's history.

The Structure of Science, by Ernest Nagel

Reviewed by Raziel Abelson

"The Structure of Science" suffers from a disparity between the brilliant clarity of the individual details and somewhat blurry quality of their over-all composition.

 November, 1961

The Trial and Eichmann

Harold Rosenberg

Can one really believe that the trial of Adolf Eichmann will deter mass murderers in the future, or that it will advance international relations?

Beyond Berlin Is There a New “Balance of Forces”?

Theodore Draper

The differences between the Soviet Union and the United States have become increasingly intractable.

The Success of Ingmar Bergman

Harris Dienstfrey

Two facts define the phenomenon of Ingmar Bergman: the twenty-one films he has made since 1945 (he wrote fourteen himself, of which eleven were original screenplays), and the striking popularity he has commanded since 1957 in the United States.

“Nine Deliberative Bodies” A Profile of the Warren Court

C. Peter Magrath

The Warren Court, which in 1956 and 1957 seemed to determined to wield a civil liberties sword at every opportunity, has since used the sword sparingly.

The Example of Lipi Lippmann A Story

Dan Jacobson

A story.

A Humanistic Guide to Foreign Aid

E. F. Schumacher

Economic misery is something altogether different from mere poverty; it is a scandal and signifies a breakdown of the natural order, for it prevents men from being human. Yet it seems to be precisely in this task that we tend to fail. The following notes attempt to find out why.

The End of an Illusion

Hans J. Morgenthau

The Berlin crisis, if we come out of it alive, can teach us some lessons about the nature of foreign policy.

Israel's Conservative Voters

Gerda Luft

The general consistency of the election returns since the formation of the State of Israel can be explained by a number of factors.

An American as Art Collector

Max Kozloff

Albert C. Barnes is an important, as well as colorful, figure and William Schack's first full-length biography of Barnes is of considerable interest.

Feiffer, Steinberg, and Others

David Segal

The comic strip made its first appearance in Hearst's "New York Journal" during the circulation war he and Pulitzer conducted in the 1890's; and it has developed since then into one of the staples of mass media entertainment.

Reformers and a Liberal

Reader Letters

The Senseless Death

Reader Letters

Kudos

Reader Letters

Covenant Theology

Reader Letters

Criticizing Mass Culture

Reader Letters

Israel and Others

Reader Letters

The End of Diplomacy

Reader Letters

Whose Canada?

Reader Letters

The Adolescent Society, by James S. Coleman; Values and Ideals of American Youth, edited by Eli Ginzberg

Reviewed by Edgar Z. Friedenberg

These two works are further evidence of the intense concern that behavioral scientists and makers of public policy have been showing for several years about the values of American youth.

The Religious Factor, by Gerhard Lenski

Reviewed by Marshall Sklare

Dr. Gerhard Lenski, with the publication of "The Religious Factor," has ably fulfilled the expectations of his colleagues, who believe him to be one of the few scholars capable of making a substantial contribution to that underdeveloped discipline in American social science: the sociology of religion.

The New Country, translated by Henry Goodman

Reviewed by Eugene Goodheart

My reaction to these "stories from the Yiddish about life in America" is complicated by a fact of my adolescence.

The Making of the President 1960, by Theodore H. White

Reviewed by Martin Mayer

An American Presidential election must be the ideal subject for a book. It is an exceedingly odd story, a unique blend of rationality, irrelevance, and folk myth-at best a catharsis, at worst a cathartic, usually a little of both.

The Traditional Prayer Book for Sabbath and Festivals, edited by David de Sola Pool; Weekday Prayer Book, edited by Gershon Hadas

Reviewed by Robert Alter

During the past year, the American Jewish community has been presented with two new "official" prayer books.

 December, 1961

The New Frontier Fulfilled

Oscar Gass

One year after the Presidential election of 1960, the New Frontier of President John F. Kennedy has acquired a firm place in a historic American series.

At Ease in Zion

Alfred Kazin

Alfred North Whitehead, that singularly clear mind, observed that even in Jesus' evasive "Render therefore unto Caesar the things which are Caesar's," one sees that the Jews had no independent state to govern; "the absence of such responsibility is one reason for their unpopularity." We are certainly more "popular" now--especially with ourselves.

The Graduate Student: A Profile

Theodore Solotaroff

Now that college education is becoming a commonplace in American life, the graduate student seems to have preempted what novelty and prestige remain in being a student.

Idiots First A Story

Bernard Malamud

A story.

James Baldwin as Spokesman

Dan Jacobson

One cannot possibly say of Baldwin that he should be occupying other, or "higher," ground; all one can ask, rather, is that he should explore even more thoroughly than he has so far done the ground upon which he is now standing.

Reading Khrushchev's Mind

R.H.S. Crossman

May we not be able to understand the Communists' behavior and predict their actions exclusively in terms of their public and publicized Communist philosophies? The question has been forced on me by reading a whole batch of books about Khrushchev--good, bad, and indifferent.

Eichmann's Victims & the Unheard Testimony

Elie Wiesel

Last month, we published an article by Harold Rosenberg which attempted to determine how far the Eichmann Trial had achieved its main purpose--that of telling the world the story of what actually happened to the European Jews under the Nazis. Here Elie Wiesel asks whether the trial did justice to Eichmann's victims.

The Study of Man: “The Long Revolution” and the British Left

Leo Marx

Americans who do not follow the debates of the British left may find it difficult to understand why "The Long Revolution" caused such a stir in England.

A Week in Warsaw

Lewis A. Coser

From this side of the Iron Curtain, Communist bloc countries tend to look alike.

Canada's Jewish Community

Reader Letters

Competing With Russia

Reader Letters

Toynbee, Pro and Con

Reader Letters

Slums and Suburbs, by James Bryant Conant

Reviewed by Martin Mayer

James Bryant Conant, formerly president of Harvard, has been speaking and writing about public schools for nearly two decades.

De Mahomet aux Marranes, by Leon Poliakov

Reviewed by Albert A. Sicroff

As with so many developments which set Spain apart from the rest of Europe, the course of Jewish history in that country owes its peculiarity to the presence there of Islam.

Marxism, by George Lichtheim

Reviewed by Dennis H. Wrong

Not many of the scores of books on Marxism that have appeared in the last few decades are likely to remain of enduring interest. George Lichtheim's magnificently compressed yet fully comprehensive study ought to be an exception.

Fighter and Prophet: The Jabotinsky Story, by Joseph B. Schechtman

Reviewed by Elias Cooper

Vladimir Jabotinsky once told his Jewish audience in Poland: "I have spoiled your children, taught them to break discipline (and sometimes windows), tried to persuade them that the true translation of kometz aleph-o is not 'learn to read' but 'learn to shoot.'"

The Nation's Safety & Arms Control, by Arthur T. Hadley; Arms Control, Disarmament & National Security, edited by Donald G. Brennan

Reviewed by Gordon A. Craig

Even discouraged observers may derive some crumbs of comfort from the sight of the remarkable number of books dealing with the arms race that have been rolling from the presses in recent years.

Advertisement

image of latest cover
image of latest cover

ADVERTISER LINKS

Advertisement