xTooltipElement
    1. Obama's Enemies List
      Peter Wehner
    2. Islamist Extremism and the Murder of Daniel Pearl
      Joseph I. Lieberman
    3. Why Obama Is Wrong on Missile Defense
      Steven Price
    4. How Politics Destroyed a Great TV Show
      Jonah Goldberg
      October 2009
    5. Why Are Jews Liberals?—A Symposium
      David Wolpe, Jonathan D. Sarna, Michael Medved, William Kristol and Jeff Jacoby
      September 2009

Advertisement



1963
View: All Months | Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec

 January, 1963

Post-Bourgeois Europe

George Lichtheim

Insofar as Western Europe is beginning to resemble the United States--in respect to income levels, social fluidity, and the breakdown of inherited class and caste structures--its society begins to reproduce some of the patterns of a modern industrial democracy with which Americans are familiar.

The Housing Order & Its Limits

Charles Abrams

On November 20, 1962--as the entire nation listened to hear the outcome of two events, either of which might have touched off a world war--President Kennedy read a prepared statement announcing that he had signed an Executive Order banning discrimination in federally aided housing.

Jewish & Other Nationalisms

H. R. Trevor-Roper

The Jews have been a European nation responding to the same general forces which have moved the other European nations. One of these forces has been that great ideological impulse which burst the old framework of Europe in the 19th-century: nationalism.

Growing Old in America

Midge Decter

It is quite impossible to look without fear upon the simple malice that can play in the face of a white-haired old woman--who is probably herself as a mother and a grandmother--as she watches an infant struggling to take his first steps. Where does such malice come from? What can it mean?

After the Cuban Crisis

Dennis H. Wrong

Whether the United States moves directly against him or not, Castro's days in power may indeed be numbered.

The Innocence of Tennessee Williams

Marion Magid

Tennessee Williams is not our best, but our only American playwright since O'Neill. His imagination magnetized though it is by the outlandish and the outre, is a kind of fever chart of our national ailments.

Israel's Three Cities

David Pryce-Jones

The meeting point of Haifa is the observation platform in the middle of Panorama Road. It is always crowded. Tel Aviv is a specifically Israeli growth. In itself Jerusalem is quite dull.

The New Secretary-General

Hans J. Morgenthau

The United Nations Charter describes the Secretary-General as "the chief administrative officer of the organization."

Festivals and Judges

Milton Himmelfarb

The last decorations will surely have been taken down from the lampposts by Lincoln's birthday, so the end of the Christmas season is in sight. The Jews of America are completing another cycle of ease and unease--in November, Thanksgiving; in December, Christmas.

American Radicalism

Reader Letters

Praise

Reader Letters

Sources of Nazism

Reader Letters

Analyzing Fagin

Reader Letters

Bar Hiya

Reader Letters

Social Criticism

Reader Letters

Literary Criticism

Reader Letters

The Warfare State, by Fred J. Cook

Reviewed by David T. Bazelon

This fellow really believes the cold war was begun, and still continues, because of a conspiracy of the American military-industrial complex: such is the entire impression the reader will take away with him from this devious potpourri of a book.

The Ghetto Game, by Dennis Clark; and A Tale of Ten Cities, edited by Eugene J. Lipman and Albert Vorspan

Reviewed by Staughton Lynd

In "The Ghetto Game," Dennis Clark joins James Conant and Michael Harrington to warn that all is far from well in "the other America."

The Soviet Revolution, 1917-1939, by Raphael R. Abramovich

Reviewed by Robert V. Daniels

Raphael Abramovich is the last great representative of the forgotten alternative to the Bolsheviks in the Russian Revolution: the true Marxists, democratic Socialists, of the Menshevik party.

The Story of Jewish Philosophy, by Joseph Blau; and The Jewish Mind, by Gerald Abrahams

Reviewed by Marvin Fox

It is encouraging that serious scholars, who do not specialize in Jewish studies, should turn their attention to Jewish thought.

Naked Lunch, by William Burroughs

Reviewed by Alfred Chester

Well, "Naked Lunch" is no work of genius but the first half of it is pleasantly readable without too much skipping, and the second half of it is pleasantly skippable without too much yawning.

 February, 1963

My Negro Problem-And Ours

Norman Podhoretz

For a long time I was puzzled to think that Jews were supposed to be rich when the only Jews I knew were poor, and that Negroes were supposed to be persecuted when it was the Negroes who were doing the only persecuting I knew about--and doing it, moreover, to me.

The Predicament of the Jewish Musician

Albert Goldman

In the last hundred and fifty years--that is, beginning with the emancipation of the Jew in Western Europe--Jews have risen to a remarkable prominence in the world of music; today one might say they virtually dominate it.

“Good Bunnies Always Obey”: Books for American Children

Jason Epstein

Ever since an 18th-century bookseller named John Newbery commissioned Oliver Goldsmith to compile the first Mother Goose, and thus launched an industry, the publication of books for children has been, among other things, a way of making money.

On Being a Candidate

H. Stuart Hughes

I find it difficult to believe that only three months ago I was a candidate for major office. Here is a paradox worth pondering. Why did I do it?

Taibele and Hurmizah A Story

Isaac Bashevis Singer

A story.

Little England

John Mander

A generation ago, not even the most rabid of Briton-baiters would have called the British an introspective people. The Cuban crisis has brought one thing home to the British very forcibly: Britannia rules the waves no more.

Responses and Reactions II

Norman Mailer

This is the second in a bi-monthly series of personal commentaries by Norman Mailer on selections from Martin Buber's two-volume collection, "Tales of the Hasidim."

The Idealism of Milovan Djilas

Bogdan Raditsa

In the period shortly before the outbreak of World War II, the Communist underground in Yugoslavia was shaken by a fierce literary and intellectual conflict. Milovan Djilas, an intransigent Stalinist intellectual, was involved.

The Modern Rabbi

Jakob J. Petuchowski

We moderns looking back can see that the ancient rabbinate did far more than hold the key to decisions in doubtful cases. They in fact adjusted more than one Biblical statute to the changing conditions of life, and to men's increasing moral sensitivity.

Raymond Chandler, Private Eye

Richard Schickel

In reading "Raymond Chandler Speaking," a collection of the late mystery writer's letters and literary fragments, one gets a sense of the peculiar loneliness of the writer of integrity who works in a popular genre that attracts few writers like himself and that the American literary culture tends to dismiss with easy, contemptuous generalizations.

On “Letting Go”

Reader Letters

Pierce Reconsidered

Reader Letters

Opus Dei

Reader Letters

Covenant Theology

Reader Letters

Rationalism in Politics, by Michael Oakeshott

Reviewed by George Lichtheim

Neo-conservatism is not as influential in the present decade as it was in the 1950's, when the postwar reaction against all forms of radicalism was in full swing. A defensive tone has once more crept into it.

Abraham Geiger and Liberal Judaism, edited by Max Wiener

Reviewed by Arthur Hertzberg

Jewish modernity as a continuous tradition is more than two hundred years old. For the most part, Jews have been occupied with all the possible permutations of the answer to one ultimate question: how can the Jew, as Jew, cease being two and become one?

World Without Want, by Paul G. Hoffman; and Economic Development in Perspective, by John Kenneth Galbraith

Reviewed by Robert L. Heilbroner

Hoffman and Galbraith, writing in the flush of the American spirit of the mid-1900's, cannot see the mountainous fact of social revolution looming over their landscape of economic development.

The Politics of Urban Renewal: The Chicago Findings, by Peter H. Rossi and Robert A. Dentler

Reviewed by Herbert J. Gans

A major problem facing any central agency in charge of a plan for urban renewal is to make certain that the plan will, finally, answer not only to the broad community interest but also to the needs and desires of the individuals who live in the area.

People and Life 1891-1921, by Ilya Ehrenburg

Reviewed by Theodore Frankel

If Ilya Ehrenburg were a conformist pure and simple, his autobiography could be expected to amount to little more than an apology for his own life. Ehrenburg has tried for considerably more.

 March, 1963

The Crisis in the Western Alliance

Hans J. Morgenthau and Graham Hutton

Two short essays on the crisis of the Atlantic Alliance. Hans Morgenthau espouses an American view while Graham Hutton maintains a British view.

My Father's Son

Mark Harris

The present essay has been adapted from Mark Harris's introduction to his new play, "Friedman and Son."

The Polish Miracle

R. H. S.

When measured in terms of economic statistics, the revival of the Polish countryside which I witnessed last summer may not rank with the revival of West German capitalism under Erhard. But it is certainly a political miracle that Gomulka should have felt able to achieve this revival.

Faigele the Idiotke A Story

Jerome Charyn

A story.

Epistles from the Eisenhower Age

Murray Kempton

The Eisenhower administration on the whole was not a bad administration so far as its policies and achievements were concerned: very little that was undertaken by the government of the United States might have been better had we in 1952 placed our destinies in anyone else's hands.

New Left Marxism

George Lichtheim

Some time ago a speaker on the BBC expressed the hope that Jean-Paul Sartre would in future devote more of his time to drama and less to philosophy. Similar observations are made occasionally in France by people whose political commitments do not differ much from those of Sartre, but who are skeptical of his claim to have effected a synthesis of Marxism and Existentialism.

People Get Hooked

R. S. Baker

The American "narcotics problem" is an artificial tragedy with real victims. One such victim was "Janet Clark," the pseudonym of a young heroin addict whose tape-recorded confessions were published in a volume titled "The Fantastic Lodge."

On “Ship of Fools”

Reader Letters

Bazelon, Pro and Con

Reader Letters

Jewish Resistance

Reader Letters

China & the U.S.

Reader Letters

Bay State Politics

Reader Letters

The Paradoxes of Freedom, by Sidney Hook

Reviewed by Lewis A. Coser

The three interrelated chapters of this book elaborate a series of lectures which the author delivered at the University of California. They all address themselves to some currently much debated issues in constitutional law.

Coat upon a Stick, by Norman Fruchter

Reviewed by Robert Alter

At a point in time when the East Side ghetto has faded in the consciousness of most younger American Jews to a blurred recollection from their parents' childhood, it seems just a little improbable that an American Jewish writer should take as the subject for his first novel the aged sexton of a dying synagogue on the East Side.

Report of the Committee on Broadcasting, by Sir Harry Pilkington & others

Reviewed by Paul Breslow

The Pilkington report is a long and repetitive amalgam of Fabian tract, aristocratic bias, puritanical concern, New Left polemic, and technical jargon produced by a committee of private citizens who had been authorized to observe and ponder the condition and influence of British broadcasting.

The National Wealth of the United States in the Postwar Period, by Raymond W. Goldsmith

Reviewed by David T. Bazelon

Society and statistics grow together, the one in size and the other in importance. This is one of the larger meanings of living in a mass technological society.

The Early Goebbels Diaries 1925-1926, edited by Helmut Heiber

Reviewed by Werner J. Dannhauser

To readers of history, these diaries of Goebbels will prove disappointing. There is little new historical information to be gained from them.

 April, 1963

Church, State, and the Jews

Arthur Hertzberg

"The time has come," editorialized the magazine "America," "for Jews to decide precisely what they conceive to be the final objective of the Jewish community in the United States." Many Jews were offended by the questions, but it is nevertheless a fair one and deserves an honest answer.

The Tax Trimmers

Robert Lekachman

Like last year's Trade Expansion Act, President Kennedy's only consequential legislative proposal for 1962, the new tax bill, is a long, intricately detailed affair which--as is usually the case with tax measures--promises to be a lawyer's delight and a layman's labyrinth.

Edward Albee: Red Herrings & White Whales

Alfred Chester

The much celebrated one- and two-act talent of Edward Albee has at last come to Broadway-sized fruition and is packing them in at the Billy Rose Theater. It is a considerable talent.

Reilly and I

Boris Weiss

Like most American Jews of my generation, I haven't had much experience with anti-Semitism. All of which is to say that I came into the following situation with little preparation and considerable confusion.

Scientists in the Classroom

Martin Mayer

Work in reforming the teaching of the sciences has been going on for seven years.

In Acknowledgment of a Chief Rabbi

Deirdre Levinson

A story.

India's Crisis: A Diary

John Mander

A diary of John Mander's visit to India.

Responses and Reactions III

Norman Mailer

This is the third in a bi-monthly series of personal commentaries by the distinguished novelist Norman Mailer on selections from Martin Buber's two-volume collection, "Tales of the Hasidim."

Hatred and Germany

Reader Letters

Against the American Grain, by Dwight Macdonald

Reviewed by Steven Marcus

For years now Dwight Macdonald has been firing off his gay and spirited salvos against the barbarians in our midst, and it would be ungrateful not to acknowledge a cumulative sense of indebtedness to him. It comes then as a disappointment to find that his essays on mass culture do not stand up on a second reading.

The Natural and the Supernatural Jew, by Arthur A. Cohen

Reviewed by Marvin Fox

In this book, Arthur Cohen asks that Judaism and the Jewish people be restored to their historic role as God's witnesses on earth.

Main Currents in Modern Economics, by Ben B. Seligman

Reviewed by C. E. Ayres

Of all the social sciences, economics has suffered most from the incompatibility of 18th-century conceptions and 20th-century mathematical techniques.

Here to Stay: Studies in Human Tenacity, by John Hersey

Reviewed by Renata Adler

When, in his introduction, John Hersey calls this a collection of "journalistic pieces," he is claiming both too little and too much.

Some Recent Jewish Books

Reviewed by Milton Himmelfarb

Some of these were first published sixty or seventy years ago, and some only a few years ago. Their republication in this form makes it possible for private and especially institutional libraries to acquire many excellent books that would otherwise be expensive and hard to come by.

 May, 1963

Disarmament & the Economy

Ben B. Seligman

Imagine the enormity of the economic problem we would face if disarmament were suddenly to emerge as a possibility.

Our Last Days in the Warsaw Ghetto

Alexander Donat

In commemoration of the twentieth anniversary of the Warsaw Ghetto uprising, which has just been celebrated throughout the world, we here present a memoir of the uprising written by a participant who survived the liquidation of the Ghetto, Alexander Donat.

Coming of Age on the Carob Plantation

George P. Elliott

Margaret Mead's specialty is interfering with her characters in such a way as also to interfere with the reader's understanding of them.

The Demise of NATO

Ronald Steel

Today NATO is floundering in a permanent state of crisis, for the two conditions on which it was built--American invulnerability and European weakness--have virtually disappeared.

Herbert H. Lehman of New York

Nathan Glazer

To anyone growing up in New York City in the 1930's, the trinity of LaGuardia, Lehman, and Roosevelt seemed as fixed and permanent as the city streets. Lehman's career is awe-inspiring in its length.

A Commentary Report: The First Electrocution

Arnold Beichman

The controversy over capital punishment that has developed in recent years generally takes place within a framework of moral principles and statistics. Perhaps the most pertinent and revealing chapter in the history of capital punishment in America is provided by the events that led up to our first legal electrocution.

On Trying to be Just

Hans J. Morgenthau

To do justice and to receive it is an elemental aspiration of man. It is as elemental as the aspiration to live on after death, to be free from the power of other men, to exert power over man and nature, to love and to be loved.

Some Attitudes Toward Jews

Milton Himmelfarb

The Jews are a nuisance to Mr. Khrushchev, and he must wish that he could wake one morning and find that they had disappeared--though not by emigration, of course.

Cuba and Peace

Reader Letters

TV, Pro and Anti

Reader Letters

Growing Old

Reader Letters

The New Europe, by George Lichtheim

Reviewed by Oscar Gass

Regarding this New Europe, Mr. George Lichtheim has written a long, and I believe excellent, political tract.

The Community of Scholars, by Paul Goodman

Reviewed by Harold Taylor

It is Paul Goodman's awareness of the reality of the educational problem as seen by students like these that makes his ideas for the reform of colleges so important a contribution to contemporary writing about education.

Faith and Prejudice, by Bernhard E. Olson

Reviewed by Martin E. Marty

Not until the publication of Bernhard E. Olson's "Faith and Prejudice" have we had a study that is careful, slow-to-wrath, and slow to generalize.

 June, 1963

At the Brink of a Test Ban

John Maddox

It is now eighteen years since the first atomic bomb was exploded in the desert of New Mexico, and for nearly a third of that time three nations--the United States, Great Britain, and the Soviet Union--have been negotiating at Geneva on a treaty to ban the testing of nuclear weapons. Today, both sides have finally arrived at an agreement.

Salinger: How to Love Without Love

Alfred Chester

Since I loved in outermost Paris during practically the whole of the 1950's, I was very late in learning of what seems to have been one of the chief American diversions during that decade: J. D. Salinger's Glass family.

France's Algerian Jews

Arnold Mandel

It has been estimated that after the Liberation there were between 150,000 and 165,000 persons of Jewish origin living in France; at present, there are between 450,000 and half a million Jews. The most recent and biggest influx thus far has been the politically stimulated mass exodus of Jews from Algeria.

Reapportionment & Liberal Myths

Alexander M. Bickel

In the decade since Earl Warren became Chief Justice of the United States, the Court over which he presides has embarked on three major enterprises of social reform--a number higher than the historical average for comparable periods, to say the least.

An Ideology of School Withdrawal

Edgar Z. Friedenberg

Compulsory school attendance in the United States has been justified from the beginning as essential to democratic polity. So far as I know, public support of education in this country has never been justified on the grounds that education was beneficial to the individual student.

The Survivor A Story

Dan Jacobson

A story.

The Politics of Conservative Realism

George Lichtheim

When a writer of Hans J. Morgenthau's standing assembles three stout volumes of essays, published over the past quarter century, he places the reviewer before a dilemma: some attempt must be made to come to terms with the author's central thesis. The dilemma can be eluded only with the aid of a utopian idealism in this case.

Responses and Reactions IV

Norman Mailer

This is the fourth in a series of commentaries by the distinguished novelist Norman Mailer on selections from Martin Buber's "Tales of the Hasidim."

Doctors, Lawyers & Other TV Heroes

Harris Dienstfrey

Television drama lately has developed a new kind of hero, the professional man.

U Thant Reexamined

Reader Letters

Tennessee Williams

Reader Letters

Cuba & the U.S.

Reader Letters

Clarification

Reader Letters

Economic Currents

Reader Letters

The Jewish Musician—I

Reader Letters

The Prophets, by Abraham J. Heschel

Reviewed by David Daiches

The Hebrew prophets were born into a world of desperate power politics, and their message was, to put it quite simply, that power politics don't matter.

The Deadlock of Democracy, by James MacGregor Burns

Reviewed by C. Vann Woodward

James MacGregor Burns, the genial professor of political science at Williams College, has a deceptively bland way of advancing revolutionary readings of the past and revolutionary proposals for the future.

Puzzles and Epiphanies, by Frank Kermode

Reviewed by Angus Wilson

At a time when the labels "provincial," "academic," and "working-class" are worn in English intellectual circles, as a sort of boy-scout proficiency badge, Frank Kermode declares his allegiance to all three states without suggesting for a moment that they are enough in themselves to justify.

The Urban Villagers, by Herbert J. Gans

Reviewed by Michael Parenti

In these times of suburban growth and urban planning, it is worth being reminded that cities, besides being centers of commerce and culture, are places where people like to live.

Reason and Conduct, by Henry David Aiken

Reviewed by Richard J. Bernstein

Anglo-American philosophers in the 20th century--despite the fact that to many people outside the field of philosophy their work has seemed to center on preoccupations very far away from what could be traditionally recognized as genuine moral problems--have invested an enormous amount of intelligence in the field called "ethics."

The Ordeal of Power, by Emmet J. Hughes

Reviewed by Jason Epstein

This little book is of no interest for what it says about Eisenhower and his administration or for what it adds to the common knowledge of recent American politics.

 July, 1963

A Commentary Report: The Puerto Ricans

Nathan Glazer

If someone twenty-five years ago had looked around at the potential sources of new immigration to New York City, his eye might well have fallen on Puerto Rico, but he would probably also have concluded that the Puerto Ricans, if they came to New York, would have a very hard time adapting.

A Dissent on Brother Daniel

Marc Galanter

In December, 1962, the Supreme Court of Israel rejected the claim of Brother Daniel, a Polish Jew who had become a Carmelite monk, that he was entitled to be admitted to Israel under the Law of Return. The decision of the court has brought into sharp focus certain questions of Jewish identity.

The Obsolescent Unions

A. H. Raskin

American unionism, thirty years after the New Deal, is in the grip of two contradictory developments.

On Second Avenue A Story

Jerome Charyn

A story.

Catholic Novels & American Culture

Thomas F. Curley

Some fifteen years ago Harry Sylvester, writing in the "Atlantic Monthly" on the problems of the Catholic writer, began with the assertion that there were no living American Catholics who were major writers. An important reason for beginning with Mr. Sylvester's essay is that it accepted a view of the Catholic writer that is still common.

Nuclear Abolitionism

Paul Kecskemeti

By now all discussion about the Problem of how to avert a nuclear catastrophe has been pretty clearly polarized into two opposite positions--usually known as deterrence and disarmament, but more fairly and accurately characterized by the terms "stabilization" and "abolition."

The Study of Man: Future-mindedness

Kathleen Nott

The English philosopher R. G. Collingwood's autobiographical account of his development provides a convincing demonstration of how good it would be if every professional thinker wrote his intellectual autobiography as a normal part of his life's work: especially if he is English or American.

The Fading Movie Star

Manny Farber

The strange evolution of movies in the last ten years--with the remaining studios ever more desperate, ever more coordinated--has brought about the disappearance of something that reviewers and film theorists have never seemed to miss: those tiny, mysterious interactions between the actor and the scene.

A Thousand Pages of Research

Anzia Yezierska

Every time I walked along Upper Broadway, I saw them. Old men and old women, in their seventies, like me, seated side by side on the park benches set up by a benevolent city on the traffic islands dissecting the main roadway.

The “Return” of Europe's Jews

Edouard Roditi

One of the most puzzling recent developments on the European literary scene has been the growing popularity, in Central and Western Europe, of books on specifically Jewish themes.

The Jewish Musician—II

Reader Letters

De Gaulle and Humanity

Reader Letters

Private Eyes

Reader Letters

Norman Mailer's Hasidism

Reader Letters

Defense of A Lady

Reader Letters

Faith and Marriage

Reader Letters

The Politics of Hope, by Arthur Schlesinger Jr.

Reviewed by Lewis A. Coser

This collection of essays, written in the 1950's and early 1960's for a variety of magazines, reflects the amazing catholicity of Mr. Schlesinger's tastes and interests.

In Search of France, by Stanley Hoffman & others

Reviewed by J. G. Weightman

Before summarizing the general thesis of this book, with which it is impossible to disagree, I may as well clear away those incidental points about which I have doubts.

The Making of Economic Society, by Robert L. Heilbroner; and The Great Ascent, by Robert L. Heilbroner

Reviewed by E. F. Schumacher

The first of Mr. Heilbroner's two new books is "an attempt to present some of the basic content of economics in [the] mingled light of theory and history." This is a most commendable undertaking. The second book is really an expanded version of the last two chapters of the first.

The USSR & the Future, edited by Leonard Schapiro; and Polycentrism, edited by Walter Z. Laqueur and Leopold Labedz

Reviewed by Robert V. Daniels

Generations of philosophers have underscored the old wisdom that just as one can never step twice into the same river, so in the flux of history there is nothing constant save the constancy of change. It should come as no surprise to observe signs of change even within that leviathan known as the Communist bloc.

The Colonial Reckoning, by Margery Perham; and Africa for Beginners, by Melvin J. Lasky

Reviewed by Roger Owen

Nobody could have predicted ten years ago the almost indecent rapidity with which the greater part of colonial Africa has been unscrambled.

The Deed, by Gerold Frank

Reviewed by Werner J. Dannhauser

A book dealing with terrorism and political assassination for the sake of the establishment of the State of Israel raises certain expectations, even when, as is the case with "The Deed," it does not necessarily treat of the most important example of such acts.

 August, 1963

A Commentary Report: The Irish of New York

Daniel P. Moynihan

The Irish era can be said to have begun with the fall of Boss Tweed in the 1870's, but the groundwork of Irish dominance was set long before that.

A Mission to Israel

Herbert Weiner

A diary from Herbert Weiner's stay in Israel.

Fortress America

Ronald Steel

Challenged by European demands for nuclear equality, the United States has replied indignantly that a European deterrent would be economically wasteful and strategically dangerous.

To Be A God

Allen Wheelis

Reflections of a psychoanalyst.

Bernard Berenson of Butremanz

Michael Fixler

In 1888 the "Harvard Monthly" published a short story by Bernard Berenson, a recent graduate of the University. The motifs and mood of the story prefigure in a striking and somber way some of the concerns that obsessed Berenson throughout his life, and of which he was not always consciously aware.

John Bull and John Profumo

John Gross

With Mr. Macmillan still in office and the case of Dr. Ward still sub judice, the Profumo crisis has yet to run its course. But whatever the eventual outcome, one thing at least is already certain: the affair has made a notable contribution to the Public Happiness.

Nasser's Decade

Alfred Sherman

Gamal Abdul Nasser has now held absolute power in Egypt for over a decade. During that time his regime has settled into a regular and recognizable--if not altogether stable--pattern.

On Paul Goodman

George Steiner

I have only once had the privilege of meeting Paul Goodman. I stress "privilege." There is no one whose encounter flatters in a more exacting way.

Responses and Reactions V

Norman Mailer

This is the fifth in a series of commentaries by the distinguished novelist Norman Mailer on selections from Martin Buber's "Tales of the Hasidim."

Suburban Anti-Semitisim

Reader Letters

Books for Children

Reader Letters

Portrait of an Addict

Reader Letters

Today's Rabbis

Reader Letters

Presidential Faith

Reader Letters

The Podhoretz Papers

Reader Letters

Ben Emunah li-Khefirah [“Between Faith and Heresy”], by Ephraim Shemuell

Reviewed by Marvin Fox

Mr. Shemueli's account of the 17th-century controversy between Leon da Modena and Uriel da Costa constitutes the major part of what is a fascinating and important study in faith and heresy--a subject that has gone quite out of fashion in our era of "dogma-less" Judaism.

Past Eve and Adam's, by Thomas F. Curley; and An Answer from Limbo, by Brian Moore

Reviewed by Richard Gilman

The writer is trapped in a mirror and the result is that his erstwhile quarry is never quite captured. Thomas Curley and Brian Moore both aspire to shatter the mirror, though by different means.

The Conservative Enemy, by C. A. R. Crosland

Reviewed by Lewis A. Coser

C. A. R. Crosland, a former Oxford Fellow in Economics and a member of Parliament, has long been associated with the Right wing of the Labor party, and his earlier book, "The Future of Socialism," is generally regarded as the most sophisticated presentation of its case. The essays collected in the present volume bring his earlier arguments up to date.

Stand Up, Friend, with Me, by Edward Field; and Final Solutions, by Frederick Seidel

Reviewed by Robert W. Flint

Edward Field's first book, "the Lamont Poetry Selection for 1963," appears when the author is thirty-nine; it is a thoroughly achieved job of work. My memory is erratic, but I can't recall another debut like that of Frederick Seidel in which a poet of solid gifts appeared so completely clothed in the mind.

In the Fiery Continent, by Tom Hopkinson; and Into Exile, by Ronald Segal

Reviewed by John Thompson

These two in their different ways fought the black man's fight as best they could; neither pretends to be anything but a white man.

 September, 1963

Test-Ban Inspections

Reader Letters

Jews, Church & State

Reader Letters

Cost of Disarmament

Reader Letters

Hannah Arendt on Eichmann:
A Study in the Perversity of Brilliance

Norman Podhoretz

One of the many ironies surrounding Hannah Arendt's book on the Eichmann trial is involved in the fact that it should have been serialized in the "New Yorker" so short a time after the appearance in the same magazine of James Baldwin's essay on the Black Muslims.

In Hazard

Dan Wakefield

I would just as soon forget about Hazard, Kentucky, a desire I share with a number of its unemployed residents, the large U.S. coal companies, the United Mine Workers of America, and the Federal Government. The effect of automation on the coal industry is not the only burden that has come to rest on the weary, stripped hills of Hazard.

Interpreting Hasidism

Martin Buber

In the October 1961 issue of "Commentary," Gershom Scholem, commonly regarded as the leading authority on Jewish mysticism, criticized Martin Buber's interpretation of Hasidism. Early this year, Rivka Schatz-Uffenheimer criticized Buber on somewhat the same grounds. The following essay was written by Martin Buber in response to these two critics.

The Good Society

Nathan Glazer

It used to be--it seems to have been so even yesterday--that people with a reforming bent of mind knew, or thought they knew, what they meant by the "good society."

A Choice of Profession

Bernard Malamud

A Story.

The Children of Birmingham

Paul Goodman

In the almost excessive reporting and other coverage of the recent events in the South, there has been amazingly little mention of the momentous success of non-violence as a political means. How and why is it working?

Justice Black and the Absolute

James Grossman

Hugo Black has never convinced the Court on his tactical point about corporations. But he has apparently established his major point, that due process has nothing to do with state regulation of business.

In The Community: The Vanishing Jews

Milton Himmelfarb

Some years ago a book called The Vanishing Irish worried about the future of Ireland, but since then the Irish have stopped vanishing. The Jews have not stopped.

Strength to Love, by Martin Luther King Jr.; The Negro Leadership Class, by Daniel C. Thompson; The New World of Negro Americans, by Harold R. Isaacs; and Lawd Today, by Richard Wright

Reviewed by Staughton Lynd

Alongside the mass marches, the Freedom Walks, the continuing heroism of voter registration in the rural Deep South, a new radicalism is taking form among the young second-level leadership of the integration movement.

Jews, God, and History, by Max I. Dimont

Reviewed by Arthur Hertzberg

Dimont's book is not history. It is not even historic myth-making.

Anti-Intellectualism in American Life, by Richard Hofstadter

Reviewed by Henry Bamford Parkes

Written with all the learning, wit, and sophistication that one has learnt to expect from Professor Hofstadter, this book brings together a mass of illuminating information about an aspect of American development which historians have not hitherto examined in any detail.

V., by Thomas Pynchon

Reviewed by Irving Feldman

"V." is a first novel by an obviously talented young writer. It is an ambitious work and asks to be taken seriously, so it would be well to get to its claims to seriousness at once.

The Miseducation of American Teachers, by James D. Koerner

Reviewed by Edgar Z. Friedenberg

Dr. Koerner's book is the latest, and quite possibly the best, in a long series of attacks on us educationists and our imputed control of the apparatus of American public education that began with Canon Bernard Iddings Bell's "Crisis in Education" in 1949.

 October, 1963

The Dropouts

Reader Letters

Warsaw Ghetto

Reader Letters

Albee vs. Chester

Reader Letters

Goldman Defended

Reader Letters

Jews & Unitarians

Reader Letters

Algerian Exodus

Reader Letters

America & the World Revolution

Lewis A. Coser, Oscar Gass, Hans J. Morgenthau and Arthur Schlesinge Jr.

Last spring, COMMENTARY invited Lewis A. Coser, Oscar Gass, Hans J. Morgenthau, and Arthur Schlesinger, Jr., to participate in a three-hour round-table discussion of America's role in the underdeveloped world.

Race-The Dream and the Nightmare

Leslie A. Fiedler

Deep in the mind of America, if not actually below, at least at the lowest level of consciousness, there exist side by side a dream and a nightmare of race relations; and the two together constitute a legend of the American frontier, of the West, or of the South.

Translating the Bible

Theodor Gaster

For the past fifty years there has been a growing feeling among scholars and ministers of religion that the time is ripe for a new English translation of the Bible.

The Comedy of Lenny Bruce

Albert Goldman

Several months ago in Chicago, the comedian Lenny Bruce was convicted of obscenity and sentenced to one year in jail and a $1000 fine.

The New Yorker and Hannah Arendt

Irving Howe

Some months ago, shortly after James Baldwin published in the New Yorker his now famous article about the Negroes, there appeared a mildly satiric comment upon it in the New Republic. Then, a few months later, when Hannah Arendt published in the "New Yorker" her equally famous articles about the Eichmann case, I found myself troubled once more, and this time with far greater urgency than after the Baldwin article.

Responses and Reactions VI

Norman Mailer

I thought this month to depart from the regular form of the column and quote no particular passages out of the "Tales of the Hasidim." No one, I think, could read Norman Podhoretz's "My Negro Problem--And Ours" without being provoked to some new ideas.

The Bombing of Germany, by Hans Rumpf

Reviewed by Marcus Cunliffe

A bothersome book: I have scribbled all over its margins. Bothersome in small ways, which prejudice the reader both against and in favor of its author.

Metatheatre, by Lionel Abel

Reviewed by Richard Gilman

"I have tried in this book," Lionel Abel writes, "to do two things: one, to explain why tragedy is so difficult, if not altogether impossible for the modern dramatist, and two, to suggest the nature of a comparably philosophic form of drama." One is impressed even before the attempt gets underway.

Basic Reader Series, published by Scott, Foresman & Co.

Reviewed by Tung Orans

Messrs. Gray, Artley, et. al., are the authors of the Think-and-Do Books, a series of workbooks designed to teach children how to read.

Free Men and Free Markets, by Robert Theobald

Reviewed by Robert L. Heilbroner

From its title, one might suspect that this was a tract in defense of laissez-faire economics, but titles can be misleading.

Before the Bible, by Cyrus H. Gordon

Reviewed by H. L. Ginsberg

Biblical Israel, for all its originality, cannot be studied in isolation from the Semitic cultures of the Ancient Near East. Yet these are not the only cultures that shed welcome light on the Bible.

 November, 1963

Reapportionment

Reader Letters

Hughes as Historian

Reader Letters

TV's Professionals

Reader Letters

Seymour: A Postscript

Reader Letters

Praise

Reader Letters

Czech-Jewish Writing

Reader Letters

Field Work in Boston

Reader Letters

Russia: Khrushchev & After

Oscar Gass

The test-ban treaty and the Sino-Soviet rift have given rise to much speculation on the degree to which the Soviet Union has actually changed under the rule of Nikita Khrushchev and on the further transformations which may reasonably be anticipated. It is to these questions that Oscar Gass addresses himself.

An Interview

Isaac Bashevis Singer

An interview with Isaac Bashevis Singer.

The Modern High School: A Profile

Edgar Z. Friedenberg

A profile of the typical modern high school.

Death in America

Robert Hellman

A Story.

Public Affairs: The Impotence of American Power

Hans J. Morgenthau

The United States has at its disposal the greatest concentration of material power existing in the world today; in view of its productive capacity and military strength, it is the most powerful nation on earth. Yet the government of that most powerful nation is incapable of making the actions of even the weakest of foreign governments conform to its desires.

Observations: The Jewish Chronicle & Others

John Gross

A well-organized exhibition devoted to the Anglo-Jewish press has just closed in London. In some ways it was a melancholy affair: dead newspapers lay in their display cases thick as autumnal leaves. But the show was built around a success story: that of the weekly "Jewish Chronicle," which for most people is the Anglo-Jewish press.

Hunger and Ideology

Steven Marcus

"The Great Hunger" is a work of unusual distinction, informed at every point by the knowledge that facts alone do not amount to history unless we include among them the fact of consciousness.

Controversy: Could Disarmament Be Policed?

Arthur I. Waskow and Paul Kecskemeti

The following exchange between Arthur I. Waskow and Paul Kecskemeti grows out of Mr. Kecskemeti's piece "Nuclear Abolitionism" (July), which raised several questions about the soundness of the idea that an international police force with a monopoly of nuclear weapons could preserve peace, law, and order in a disarmed world.

The Survivors, by Norbert Muhlen

Reviewed by Theodore Frankel

The World Is a Wedding, by Bernard Kops

Reviewed by Jonathan Miller

This is a daft, rather sad book and the fact that it made its way into print at all says something about the sentiment of the English Left since Suez.

The Abolitionists, by Louis Ruchames

Reviewed by Harvey Swados

This anthology of the early writings and exhortations of the abolitionists, principally from 1830 to 1848, inevitably takes on special significance in 1963.

Writers at Work, edited by George Plimpton

Reviewed by Erik Wensberg

If the purpose served in giving these literary interviews their present title is nothing so homely as exactitude, the choice does suggest that the publisher knows where we itch.

Outsiders, by Howard S. Becker

Reviewed by Harris Dienstfrey

"Outsiders," Howard S. Becker's study of deviance, is mostly an insider's view. Becker belongs to the group of sociologists, usually called "interactionists," who examine social behavior from the viewpoint of the actor.

On Tyranny, by Leo Strauss

Reviewed by George Lichtheim

The reappearance in print of Professor Strauss's study "On Tyranny" derives its special interest from circumstances only indirectly connected with the original publication.

 December, 1963

An Exchange

Reader Letters

The Good Society

Reader Letters

Russian Art & Anti-Semitism: Yevtushenko vs. Khrushchev; A Speech by Mikhail Romm

Nikita S. Khrushchev, Yevgeny Yevtushenko and Mikhail Romm

For months now, typed manuscripts of Krushchev's exchanges with intellectuals--purporting to give the texts of who said what, to whom, where, and when--have passed from hand to hand and have been read by many thousands. One of these typescripts appears below, together with the text of a speech by Mikhail Romm.

Non-Rule in America

David T. Bazelon

The first great issue in American history was whether we were to have a federal government at all; its final resolution took about a hundred years. The second great issue of American history--which remains unresolved after another hundred years--is whether the federal government, now that we have it, is ever going to be allowed to govern.

Writing About Jews

Philip Roth

Ever since some of my first stories were published in 1959 in a volume called "Goodbye, Columbus," my work has been attacked from certain pulpits and in certain periodicals as dangerous, dishonest, and irresponsible. It is difficult, if not impossible, to explain to some of the people claiming to have felt my teeth sinking in, that in many instances they haven't been bitten at all.

West African Diary

John Mander

A diary from John Mander's visit to West Africa.

Kant and Judaism

Emil L. Fackenheim

However much the revealed morality of Judaism and the rational morality of pre-Kantian philosophy may quarrel about the content of moral law, they have no necessary quarrel concerning its foundations.

The Tory Succession: A London Letter

George Lichtheim

Caligula made his horse a Consul; Mr. Macmillan has made Lord Home--or Sir Alexander Douglas-Home, as he is henceforth to be known--Prime Minister. That, more or less, sums up the reaction of the more cynical commentators to the surprising outcome of our latest political upheaval.

Stella

Sydor Rey

A Story.

Anti-Communism and the Corporations

Alan F. Westin

Throughout the United States today, hundreds of corporations are energetically engaged in programs to "educate" Americans about the nature and threat of Communism. It is hard to fix the cost of these programs, but the total cannot be less than twenty-five million dollars a year.

The Group, by Mary McCarthy

Reviewed by Thomas Rogers

The chief opinion about Mary McCarthy is that she is brilliant. But what is she brilliant about?

The Benefactor, by Susan Sontag; and Nickel Miseries, by Ivan Gold

Reviewed by Robert W. Flint

Susan Sontag and Ivan Gold have in common their birth in New York within a year of each other and their very considerable gifts as writers.

Confusions, by Jack Ludwig; The War of Camp Omongo, by Burt Blechman; and Stick Your Neck Out, by Mordecai Richler

Reviewed by Stanley Kauffmann

It's all very well for critics to announce that the novel is dying. They dust off their hands, then turn away to cozy exegeses of Joyce or Proust. But what about the unlucky fellow who has been born with novelistic talent? What is he supposed to do?

Advertisement

image of latest cover
image of latest cover

ADVERTISER LINKS

Advertisement