xTooltipElement
    1. Obama's Enemies List
      Peter Wehner
    2. Islamist Extremism and the Murder of Daniel Pearl
      Joseph I. Lieberman
    3. Why Obama Is Wrong on Missile Defense
      Steven Price
    4. How Politics Destroyed a Great TV Show
      Jonah Goldberg
      October 2009
    5. Why Are Jews Liberals?—A Symposium
      David Wolpe, Jonathan D. Sarna, Michael Medved, William Kristol and Jeff Jacoby
      September 2009

Advertisement



November 1961

E-mail Article Reserve Article Download PDF Version
Yes, I would like to receive periodic updates and information via e-mail from Commentary.

Thank You

A link to

"The Trial and Eichmann"

has been emailed to your friends.

Most E-mailed articles:

Abstract –

IN THIS HARSH world draw thy breath in pain to tell my story," the dying Hamlet begged his friend Horatio. Telling can, apparently, require a sacrifice-in Hamlet's view, the supreme sacrifice of remaining alive. Why tell it then? What good will it do? It is a shocking story; to repeat it can only induce bad dreams, particularly in the few survivors of the bloody tragedy. Also, the story is confused and points to no edifying conclusion. For Horatio to accede to Hamlet's appeal, the passion of the friend and the poet must overcome the impulse of the man to seek relief from the past in oblivion.

Human beings, we assume, are entitled to peace of mind, and this privilege ought to be surrendered only if it can be demonstrated that the recalling of miseries will serve some useful purpose-that of social therapy perhaps, or of patriotism, or of progress toward a better world. Thus press reports of the trial of "The Attorney General versus Adolf, the son of Adolf Karl Eichmann" concluded their horrid accounts by arguing apologetically that virtuous ends might be furthered: "It is hoped," ran the refrain, "that bringing these evils to light will prevent anything like them from ever happening again." Dr. Servatius, chief attorney for the defense, asked in his summation that the case be determined in such a way as to "serve as a warning signpost for history" and a contribution to the cause of peace.


About the Author

Harold Rosenberg, a veteran contributor to COMMENTARY, was educated at the City College of New York and Brooklyn Law School, passing the New York State Bar examination in 1927. Best known as a critic of painting and literature, he has also written widely on politics and society. His book, The Tradition of the New, was issued by Horizon Press in 1959; and scheduled for publication soon, is his recently completed study of the painter Arshile Gorky.

Advertisement

image of latest cover
image of latest cover

ADVERTISER LINKS

Advertisement