Crossing the Line Between Satire and Hate

Last year, I took issue with Forward cartoonist Eli Valley’s Halloween graphic in which he explained why Israel was inevitably heading toward absorption into a majority Palestinian state. That was a nasty piece of agitprop combining tastelessness with shameless distortions of history. But in comparison to this year’s edition, I have to admit it seems a bit more reasonable than I thought it was at the time. After all, arguing that Israel’s defenders are harming it may be unreasonable and disconnected from reality, but underneath Valley’s deliberate attempts to outrage Jewish and Zionist sensibilities there is an argument, even if it is a foolish one.

0
Shares
Google+ Print

Crossing the Line Between Satire and Hate

Must-Reads from Magazine

The Flaw in the Right’s Media Hate

Hating the media won't result in one legislative victory.

By all accounts, America’s elite business and political leaders now live in abject terror of a singular phenomenon; a capricious beast that strikes without warning: Donald Trump’s tweets. It is a sad commentary on the cowardice of our alleged best and brightest that the object of their fears is a paper tiger.

28
Shares
Google+ Print

The Clock Is Ticking, GOP

The GOP has a narrow window to get their agenda through.

So far, 2017 is what 2009 looked like on Earth 2.

17
Shares
Google+ Print

One States, Two States, Whatever

Commentary podcast: A new pathway to peace abroad and a new war at home.

On the second Commentary podcast of the week, we (Abe Greenwald, Noah Rothman, and I) dilate upon Donald Trump’s seeming revolution in the U.S. posture toward the Israelis and the Palestinians while asking this question: Does the president actually know what the “one-state” or “two-state” solution is? We also point out that just as paranoids have enemies, Trump has reason to believe he is under attack from inside his own executive branch—but that his response may hurt him and not help. Also, like Jack Benny and Fred Allen’s radio shows of old, we have a sponsor! Give a listen.

9
Shares
Google+ Print

An Unconventional Middle East Peace?

A Middle East peace that abandons the Peace Process.

It was a shock to the status quo on Tuesday when, standing beside Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, President Donald Trump abandoned decades of U.S. policy by suggesting he would no longer insist on a two-state solution as a prerequisite for peace. Trump went on to demonstrate his contempt for precedent by noting that Palestinian school children are “taught hate from a very young age.” Trump’s disregard for diplomatic niceties may yet end up causing him headaches, but he could also find the restive Middle East more receptive to a breakthrough. Ironically, it was Barack Obama who made Trump’s job of pursuing an out-of-the-box solution to the region’s conflicts all the easier, albeit inadvertently.

15
Shares
Google+ Print

Is BDS a Bust?

BDS has failed to turn Israel into a pariah state.

In 2005, a coalition of organizations claiming to represent Palestinian civil society issued a call to boycott, divest from, and sanction Israel. Since then, the BDS movement has acted, in church organizations, on college campuses, and elsewhere, to make Israel the equivalent of apartheid-era South Africa; a pariah state. BDS has been active in the U.S., and COMMENTARY has covered many of its individual wins and losses. But it is worth pausing every now and again to consider its overall effect on American public opinion.

17
Shares
Google+ Print