Muslims and the First Amendment

For the past several years, there have been two competing narratives about Islam in America. One put forward by groups that purport to represent believers in Islam and the liberal media would have it that in the post-9/11 era, American Muslims are besieged by a wave of hatred and violence (even though there is no statistical evidence to back up such claims). The other is one articulated by critics of Islam who argue that Muslims are demanding and getting accommodations from government and other institutions that are an unconstitutional establishment of Islamic or Sharia law. Advocates of this point of view are the driving force behind efforts to enact laws that would prohibit recognition or use of Sharia law in U.S. courts. This cause has often seemed to be, at best, the result of overblown fears because, unlike in Asia and Africa where Muslim efforts to make Sharia the law of the land, there is little danger of that happening in Oklahoma or other states where anti-Sharia statutes have been proposed.

0
Shares
Google+ Print

Muslims and the First Amendment

Must-Reads from Magazine

The Left’s Nuclear Delusions Die Hard

The age of paranoia.

By December of 2016, the imminent prospect of handing control of America’s nuclear arsenal over to Donald Trump already had the American left on edge. The president-elect sent them careening over the brink when he offered some thoughts on U.S. nuclear policy on Twitter.

12
Shares
Google+ Print

Please Help COMMENTARY Enlighten

News moves at the speed of light. Enlightenment doesn't.

I need to ask you a favor. You’re here because you value COMMENTARY. And we’re here because we value our mission, which is to do what we can to enlighten our readers about the immensely confusing days through which we are living. We all need to follow the news as it happens. And we also need enlightenment—to understand what the news is doing to our lives, to our countries, to our civilization. If you can, please help COMMENTARY—a non-profit 501 c 3 organization that relies not only on subscribers but also on donors to keep doing what we’ve been doing.

2
Shares
Google+ Print

Blame Voters

The kid gloves come off.

No one should be too proud of the fact that the election of a Democrat to the U.S. Senate from Alabama over a spectacularly flawed, theocratic, credibly accused child abuser with a unique contempt for the law came as a surprise. And yet, it did, and the implications of that shock Democratic victory prompted the formation of a particularly animated circular firing squad. With a once-safe Senate majority now in real peril for 2018, Republicans are looking for someone to blame. Fortunately for them, theirs is a target-rich environment.

23
Shares
Google+ Print

Steve Bannon Defanged

Out of his league.

Roy Moore’s defeat in Tuesday’s special election in Alabama has many salutary effects. It ensures that a man credibly accused of preying on teenagers won’t get anywhere close to the U.S. Senate, the world’s greatest deliberative body. It also means that his nutsy ideas–he opposes Muslims running for high office, believes Barack Obama wasn’t born in the U.S., and thinks America would have been better off without most of the Amendments to the Constitution–won’t be broadcast from a prestigious national stage. And it bars the left from tarring every elected Republican with Moore’s creepiness (the personal and ideological).

13
Shares
Google+ Print

The Future of the GOP With No Moore Roy

Podcast: Moore-osity

The stunning result in the Alabama special election offers the crew at the COMMENTARY podcast (me, Noah Rothman, Abe Greenwald, and Sohrab Ahmari) a chance to reflect on how we got here, what this says about Donald Trump and Steve Bannon, and whether hatches can be sufficiently battened down to withstand the tidal wave coming for the Republican Party in 2018. Give a listen.

10
Shares
Google+ Print