The Conversion Issue

While most eyes today will be on Israel’s Labor Party convention and its scheduled vote on joining Binyamin Netanyahu’s coalition, another important political story is barely getting attention. That is, the refusal of the ultra-Orthodox United Torah Judaism (UTJ) to sign a coalition deal, because of differences with Avigdor Lieberman’s Israel Beiteinu over the issue of conversion. Lieberman is known around the world mostly for his views on the Arab-Israeli conflict, but as a representative of the very large community of Russian immigrants to Israel he also holds strong views on church-state relations — views that often contradict those of Netanyahu’s other “natural” political partners, the religious-right parties. Thus, we get this new crisis:

In coalition talks with the Likud, Lieberman’s party was able to extract concessions on reforms in the conversion process. Yet these clauses in the agreement were deemed unacceptable by the spiritual head of UTJ, Rabbi Yosef Shalom Elyashiv, thus leading to an impasse in coalition talks with the Likud.

Lieberman’s achievement seems technical in nature. It will authorize rabbis of municipalities to oversee conversions, thus diminishing the ultra-Orthodox monopoly over all conversions. The ultra-Orthodox control the chief rabbinate, but in different parts of the country some moderate rabbis are more attuned to the needs of local communities, among them Russian immigrants with whom questions of conversion can be very sensitive.

A senior rabbinic figure and critic of the conversion reforms who is close to Elyashiv told The Jerusalem Post last week that past experiences have shown that allowing city rabbis to perform
conversions tends to lead to bribery. “A local rabbi is liable to be exposed to all sorts of economic pressures from residents of his town,” said the source.

Of course, the fractures within the ultra-Orthodox camp don’t help to clarify matters. Some of Netanyahu’s aides believe that the new crisis is more a sign of struggle between the two rival camps comprising this party. Earlier in the process, there were signs that UTJ would be ready to make some compromises in order to join the coalition. But on the conversion issue, there’s very little chance that the party will change its position, and efforts are now being made to convince Lieberman to show some flexibility, and to agree to amend the already-signed agreement he has with Likud.

0
Shares
Google+ Print

The Conversion Issue

Must-Reads from Magazine

Republicans Need to Prepare for the Worst

Expect the impossible.

If the 2016 presidential election cycle demonstrated anything, it was that Republicans suffer from a crippling lack of imagination. That ordeal should have established that the unprecedented is not impossible. Even now, Republicans seem as though they are trying to convince themselves that their eyes are lying to them, but they are not. The tempo of the investigation into President Trump is accelerating, and a nightmare scenario is eminently imaginable. Only congressional Republicans can avert disaster, and only then by being clear about the actions they are prepared to take if Trump instigates a crisis of constitutional legitimacy.

48
Shares
Google+ Print

Can Turkey be Trusted with F-35s?

Are the warplane's secrets safe?

The F-35 Joint Strike Fighter is the newest generation air platform for the U.S. Air Force, Navy, and Marines. Lockheed-Martin, which builds the F-35, describes it as “a 5th Generation fighter, combining advanced stealth with fighter speed and agility, fully fused sensor information, network-enabled operations and advanced sustainment.” For both diplomatic reasons and to encourage sales, Lockheed-Martin subcontracted the production of many F-35 components to factories abroad. Many program partners—Australia, Canada, the United Kingdom, Denmark, for example—are consistent U.S. allies.

30
Shares
Google+ Print

The Trump Right’s Martyrdom of Kim Guadagno

Too many martyrs make a movement.

If the GOP is to be converted into a vehicle for politicians who evince Donald Trump’s brand of pragmatic center-right populism, Trump will have to demonstrate his brand of politics can deliver victories for people other than himself. Presidential pen strokes help to achieve that, as do judicial appointments. Nothing is so permanent, though, as sweeping legislative change. On that score, the newly Trumpian Republican Party is coming up short. If the passive process of transformational legislative success fails to compel anti-Trump holdouts in the GOP to give up the ghost, there is always arm-twisting. It seems the Republican National Committee is happy to play enforcer.

13
Shares
Google+ Print

The Conservative Crack-Up, 2017 Edition

Podcast: Conservatism in shackles while O.J. goes free?

On the second of this week’s podcasts, I ask Abe Greenwald and Noah Rothman whether the health-care debacle this week is simply a reflection of the same pressures on the conservative coalition Donald Trump saw and conquered by running for president last year—and what it will mean for him and them that he has provided no rallying point for Republican politicians. And then we discuss OJ Simpson. Give a listen.

4
Shares
Google+ Print

Macron’s Terrorism Idiocy

Hyperbole yields cynicism, not the other way around.

Newly-elected French President Emmanuel Macron surprised almost everyone when he invited President Donald Trump to celebrate Bastille Day with him in Paris, especially after the two leaders’ awkward first meeting in Brussels in May. After all, between now and then, Trump withdrew the United States from the Paris Climate Change Agreement, and Macron has become perhaps the most vocal critic of Trump among European leaders.

15
Shares
Google+ Print